| 100% | NAME | 4 | "What's My ___?" (Rihanna song) |
| 100% | NAME | 4 | "What's My ___?" (2010 Rihanna hit song) |
| 91% | NAME | 4 | "What's My ___" (Rihanna's hit song) |
| 76% | NAME | 4 | "What's My ___?" (2010 Rihanna hit) |
| 75% | AGE | 3 | "What's My ___ Again?" (Blink-182 song) |
| 69% | SEA | 3 | What my Bonnie lies over, in a song |
| 69% | NAME | 4 | "What's My ___?" (Rihanna hit) |
| 68% | THEYVE | 6 | "Look What __ Done to My Song, Ma" |
| 67% | PLENIPOTENTIARY | 15 | What's my line: #3 |
| 67% | PARLIAMENTARIAN | 15 | What's my line: #2 |
| 67% | PRESTIDIGITATOR | 15 | What's my line: #1 |
| 67% | PANELS | 6 | What's My Line? features |
| 65% | THEYVE | 6 | "Look What ___ Done to My Song, Ma" (1970 hit) |
| 65% | NANA | 4 | Syllables in Rihanna's "What's My Name?" |
| 62% | DIAMONDS | 8 | Rihanna's "shine bright" song |
| 62% | ORE | 3 | What's found in an iron mine |
| 62% | CERF | 4 | Early What's My Line? panelist |
| 61% | AGE | 3 | “What’s My ___ Again?” (Blink-182 song with the lyric “Nobody likes you when you’re twenty-three”) |
| 60% | DID | 3 | Fall Out Boy's "My Songs Know What You ___ in the Dark (Light 'Em Up)" |
| 59% | COMES | 5 | What's between here and the sun, in song? |
| 59% | JAM | 3 | "That's my ___!" ("I LOVE that song!") |
| 59% | JAM | 3 | "That's my ___" ("I love that song!") |
| 59% | ROSES | 5 | What everything's coming up, in song |
| 59% | SAY | 3 | "___ My Name" (Destiny's Child song) |
| 57% | TEAPOT | 6 | What "I" am, in a kid's song |
| 57% | SAY | 3 | "___ My Name," song by Destiny's Child |
| 57% | DRINKINGBUDDY | 13 | "Okay, so what's my problem, bartender?" |
| 57% | SKIP | 4 | "___ to My Lou" (children's song) |
| 57% | LOU | 3 | "Skip to My ___" (children's song) |