| 100% | FLEECE | 6 | "What is a sheep's favorite Christmas song? ___ Navidad!" |
| 56% | SOY | 3 | "What is a vegan's favorite Christmas carol? ___ to the World!" |
| 55% | WHITE | 5 | What the color of Bing Crosby's Christmas is, in a 1942 song? |
| 53% | LUCKY | 5 | What is a leprechaun's favorite cereal? "___ Charms!" |
| 47% | SNOWMAN | 7 | What Frosty is, in a Christmas song |
| 47% | THETIMES | 8 | What are a-changin', in a Dylan song |
| 46% | GREATDAY | 8 | What "there's gonna be," in a "Funny Lady" song |
| 44% | TEAPOT | 6 | What "I" am, in a kid's song |
| 44% | SEALED | 6 | What the Go-Go's lips are in a 1981 song |
| 44% | JUNGLEBELLS | 11 | Tarzan's favorite Christmas song? |
| 42% | AMORE | 5 | What that is, in a 1953 song |
| 42% | OPENDOOR | 8 | What love is, per a "Frozen" song |
| 42% | ROYALTIES | 9 | What may be gotten for a song? |
| 41% | YOU | 3 | What Mariah Carey wants for Christmas in a 1994 song? |
| 41% | SEXY | 4 | What Justin Timberlake was bringing back, in a 2006 song |
| 40% | MOMMY | 5 | I am a character from a popular Christmas song who kisses Santa Claus |
| 40% | SEXY | 4 | What Justin Timberlake is bringing back, in a 2006 hit song |
| 40% | SEDATED | 7 | What the Ramones wanted to be in a 1978 hit song |
| 39% | THEBOSS | 7 | What James Brown “paid the cost to be,” in a 1973 song |
| 38% | CHAIN | 5 | What a "series" of fools may be called, according to an Aretha Franklin song? |
| 38% | AMEN | 4 | Beyoncé song with the lyric “Say a prayer for what has been” |
| 38% | ODOR | 4 | A Christmas tree's is piney |
| 37% | SHIP | 4 | What a fool might be using to cross the sea, according to a Grateful Dead song? |
| 37% | ESTATE | 6 | What's passed along in a will |
| 37% | LAW | 3 | What a dictator's word is |
| 37% | TRUCKIN | 7 | Grateful Dead song with the lyric “What a long, strange trip it’s been” |
| 37% | TRIBE | 5 | What many a U.S. state is named after |
| 36% | BASS | 4 | What Meghan Trainor's song is "all about" |
| 36% | PUP | 3 | What's usually in a "barking" Christmas present |
| 36% | RENT | 4 | What's to be paid to a landlord |