| 100% | UPON | 4 | "When You Wish ___ a Star" |
| 100% | UPON | 4 | "When you wish ___ a star ..." |
| 100% | UPON | 4 | ''When you wish __ a star . . .'' |
| 100% | UPON | 4 | ''When You Wish __ a Star'' |
| 100% | UPON | 4 | "When You Wish __ a Star" |
| 100% | PINOCCHIO | 9 | When You Wish Upon a star is a song in this film |
| 95% | UPON | 4 | "When You Wish ___ a Star" (song from "Pinocchio") |
| 90% | NED | 3 | "When You Wish Upon a Star" lyricist Washington |
| 88% | NED | 3 | ___ Washington, who wrote "When You Wish Upon a Star" |
| 88% | JIMINYCRICKET | 13 | Character who sings "When You Wish Upon a Star" |
| 80% | WISHUPON | 8 | When You __ a Star, Pinocchio song |
| 78% | SEXSCENE | 8 | When you might see a star's moon? |
| 73% | STAR | 4 | "When You Wish Upon a __" |
| 70% | BUTTHEBEST | 10 | When prefixed with 72-Across, what a friend wishes for you |
| 70% | STAR | 4 | "When You Wish Upon a ___" (song from "Pinocchio") |
| 69% | WISH | 4 | "When You __ Upon a Star" |
| 67% | WISH | 4 | "When You ___ Upon a Star" |
| 67% | SHOOTING | 8 | The type of star you're told to make a wish on |
| 67% | WISH | 4 | You might make one when you see a falling star |
| 67% | UPONASTAR | 9 | When You Wish __, popular Disney anthem |
| 65% | DROPTHEBEAT | 11 | Demand to a DJ, and what you must do when entering the starred answers |
| 63% | WISH | 4 | "When You ___ Upon a Star" ("Pinocchio" song) |
| 63% | STAR | 4 | "When You Wish Upon A ___," song from Disney's film "Pinocchio" sung by Cliff Edwards |
| 62% | GENIE | 5 | Wish-granter that comes out when you rub a lamp |
| 62% | MOVINGDAY | 9 | When you might rent a van |
| 62% | SPARETIME | 9 | When you might solve a puzzle |
| 62% | BORE | 4 | "A person who talks when you wish him to listen," per Ambrose Bierce |
| 61% | UPON | 4 | Wish ___ a star |
| 61% | DOODAD | 6 | When you can't remember a name |
| 61% | ETA | 3 | When you can expect a touchdown (abbr.) |