| 100% | ODDLY | 5 | "You'd never have guessed, but ..." |
| 58% | GETWELL | 7 | Type of card you likely wish you'd never have got, but hey, it's better than "condolences!" |
| 51% | PENPAL | 6 | Friend you may never have met |
| 51% | PENPALS | 7 | Friends you may never have met |
| 50% | WOE | 3 | You and I have nothing but sadness |
| 50% | WOE | 3 | You and I have nothing but misery |
| 50% | WOE | 3 | You and I have nothing but grief |
| 50% | WOE | 3 | You and I have nothing but gloom |
| 49% | ANYIDEA | 7 | "Do you have a guess?" |
| 48% | THERE | 5 | "I guess you had to be ___" |
| 48% | ESP | 3 | "Do you have ___?" ("That guess was uncanny!") |
| 47% | GEE | 3 | "I'd never have suspected!" |
| 46% | ITSO | 4 | "You've never had ___ good" |
| 46% | STAIR | 5 | It takes you up and down but never moves |
| 46% | PEN | 3 | With 40-Down, friend you may have never met |
| 46% | RUEBARRYMORE | 12 | Wish you had never met the star of “Firestarter”? |
| 46% | WHOKNEW | 7 | "Could you have guessed that?": 2 wds. |
| 46% | WHOKNEW | 7 | ''Would you have guessed?'' [last letter] |
| 45% | ASK | 3 | "I thought you’d never ___!" |
| 45% | ASK | 3 | "Thought you'd never ___" |
| 45% | ITSO | 4 | "You never had — good!" |
| 45% | ITSO | 4 | “You never had — good!” |
| 45% | ITSO | 4 | “You never had ___ good!” |
| 45% | ITSO | 4 | ''You never had __ good!'' |
| 45% | ITSO | 4 | "You never had __ good!" |
| 45% | GOHOME | 6 | "You don't have to ___, but you can't stay here" |
| 45% | EWER | 4 | It has a lip and a mouth but never speaks |
| 45% | EVER | 4 | Never have I ___, fun party game where you spill secrets without really saying "I've done that" |
| 44% | FALSE | 5 | Test answer you have a 50/50 chance of guessing right |
| 44% | YESNO | 5 | Kind of question you have a 50% chance of guessing correctly |