| 100% | SLAY | 4 | "You ___ me!" ("That's hysterical!") |
| 81% | FATHERTIME | 10 | "___? That's when you're hanging out with me" |
| 81% | HATE | 4 | Rihanna's "___ That I Love You" |
| 80% | ALLINTHEFAMILY | 14 | "___? That's you, me, your mom, and your other relatives" |
| 80% | BOTTLEEPISODE | 13 | "___? That's an instance of when I'm feeding you" |
| 79% | HATE | 4 | Rihanna's track "___ That I Love You" |
| 73% | ASK | 3 | "That's all I ___ of you" |
| 72% | IMIT | 4 | "That's me you're looking for" |
| 72% | AMI | 3 | "You think that's true about me?" |
| 72% | NOLIE | 5 | "And that's ___" ("Believe you me") |
| 71% | APE | 3 | You (or me, for that matter), biologically |
| 71% | HATE | 4 | "___ That I Love You" (Rihanna song) |
| 71% | HATE | 4 | "___ That I Love You" (Rihanna hit) |
| 70% | HATE | 4 | Rihanna, "___ that I Love You" |
| 70% | FINE | 4 | "That's another ___ mess you've gotten me into!" |
| 69% | SEE | 3 | "That's what I was trying to tell you!" |
| 69% | LET | 3 | "Please, ___ me get that for you" |
| 69% | ALLOWME | 7 | "May I do that for you?" |
| 69% | WHOME | 5 | "Wait, you think I did that?" |
| 68% | NICKELBACK | 10 | "How You Remind Me" band that had a 2005 hit that shared 18-Across's title |
| 68% | DUH | 3 | ''Sure, now that you've told me!'' |
| 68% | OHGOD | 5 | "Tell me you didn't say that" |
| 68% | AMI | 3 | "Is that what you think of me?" |
| 68% | HOW | 3 | "___ dare you talk to me like that!" |
| 68% | TRASHCANWETRASHTALK | 19 | Garbage receptacle that you and I insult? |
| 67% | SEZ | 3 | "___ me, that's who!" |
| 67% | ABOVEMYPAYGRADE | 15 | "That's why you get the big bucks and not me" |
| 67% | VAGUENESS | 9 | Quality that's often expressed when you utter the phrase "You know what I mean," or "sorta" or "about" |
| 67% | BADIDEA | 7 | "I wouldn't do that if I were you" |
| 67% | BADIDEA | 7 | “I wouldn’t do that if I were you” |