| 100% | CALL | 4 | "You Can ___ Me Al," 1986 Paul Simon hit inspired by a party where he was mistakenly referred to as "Al" |
| 31% | ALLYOUCAN | 9 | A bottomless buffet can be referred to as __ eat |
| 29% | CAN | 3 | "You ___ Call Me Al," Paul Simon hit |
| 29% | TOUCHSTONE | 10 | Court jester in Shakespeare's "As You Like It" who is referred to as a "natural fool" |
| 28% | SHE | 3 | "April Come ___ Will," 1966 song by Simon & Garfunkel whose title refers to a woman |
| 28% | POSITIVE | 8 | "Yes, I am sure!" as you'd say to a commanding officer? |
| 28% | EDIE | 4 | Singer Brickell (married to Paul Simon) whose biggest hit was 1988's "What I Am" |
| 28% | LINE | 4 | Turkey talk-___, venture by Butterball where you can make a call to ease your turkey woes |
| 27% | CICADA | 6 | Insect often mistakenly referred to as a locust |
| 27% | SKYWALKER | 9 | 2017 R&B hit by Miguel whose title could refer to a "Star Wars" protagonist: 2 wds. |
| 27% | MAN | 3 | Can be referred to as "common" |
| 27% | LONELYBOY | 9 | Hit song by Paul Anka which was also used as the title of the documentary made on him: 2 wds. |
| 27% | MISSING | 7 | "___ You," 1984 song performed by Diana Ross that had been written by Lionel Richie as a tribute to Marvin Gaye |
| 27% | DOWN | 4 | "Eastbound & ___," sports comedy series produced by Will Ferrell where he appears in a recurring role as Ashley Schaeffer |
| 27% | WAY | 3 | "Find My ___," song by Paul McCartney that can be added to a "Lost & Found" playlist |
| 26% | FREE | 4 | "...One thing I can tell you is you got to be ___" ("Come Together" by The Beatles) |
| 26% | MAYBELLENE | 10 | Song by 17-Across in which he asks a girl, "Why can't you be true?" |
| 26% | CAN | 3 | "You ___ Call Me Al," Paul Simon hit that features in season 5 of "The Office" |
| 26% | OOF | 3 | EP that sounds as though you've been hit by a brick, released by Seattle's duo "Blue Scholars" in 2009 |
| 26% | STY | 3 | A messy, filthy room might be referred to as this |
| 26% | EBERT | 5 | He said "I learned to be a movie critic by reading Mad magazine" |
| 26% | GROOVY | 6 | Paul Simon sings "Life I love you, all is __" |
| 26% | ROLLING | 7 | The ___ Stones, "(I Can't Get No) Satisfaction" band whose name was inspired by a Muddy Waters song |
| 26% | KIN | 3 | “i’ve left Earth to find a place where my ___ can be safe”: Danez Smith |
| 25% | PRESLEY | 7 | Elvis ___, a singer who is often referred to as "The King of Rock and Roll" |
| 25% | LIKE | 4 | "___ I ran over its dog," quote said by Norm on "Cheers" as a response to the question "How's life treating you, Norm?" |
| 25% | ATTHEZOO | 8 | Where "giraffes are insincere," in a Simon & Garfunkel hit |
| 25% | ELLA | 4 | I am referred to as the "Queen of Jazz" and I won fourteen Grammys |
| 25% | YMCA | 4 | Where there are "many ways to have a good time," in a 1978 hit |
| 25% | TEXAS | 5 | U.S. state where one can be legally married by agreeing to it, living together, and telling others you are married |