| 100% | THEDROWSY | 9 | & 11D Lisa Lambert and Greg Morrison stage show; 2006 Tony Award Best Musical nominee |
| 40% | JERSEYBOYS | 10 | 2006 Tony Award Best Musical winner based on the story of Frankie Valli and the Four Seasons |
| 34% | MAMMAMIA | 8 | 2002 Tony Award Best Musical nominee featuring the songs of pop group Abba |
| 31% | LAMAS | 5 | Fernando —, 1957 Tony Award Best Actor in a Musical nominee for Happy Hunting |
| 31% | RENT | 4 | Tony Award winner for Best Musical between "Sunset Boulevard" and "Titanic" |
| 31% | GROUNDHOGDAY | 12 | 2017 Tony Award nominee for Best Musical (2 wds.) |
| 31% | COMEFROMAWAY | 12 | 2017 Tony Award nominee for Best Musical (3 wds.) |
| 30% | LOESSER | 7 | Frank —, 1951 Tony Award for Best Musical winner for Guys and Dolls |
| 30% | TIMCURRY | 8 | 2005 Tony Award Best Actor in a Musical nominee for his role as King Arthur in Spamalot |
| 29% | CURRY | 5 | Tim —, 2005 Tony Award Best Actor in a Musical nominee for his role as King Arthur in Spamalot |
| 29% | LOESSER | 7 | Frank —, winner of the 1951 Tony Award for Best Musical for Guys and Dolls |
| 29% | ANNIE | 5 | Charles Strouse and Martin Charnin show; 1977 Tony Award winner for Best Musical and Best Original Score |
| 29% | ANNIE | 5 | Charles Strouse and Martin Charnin show; 1977 Tony Award-winner for Best Musical and Best Original Score |
| 29% | MANOF | 5 | & 22A Mitch Leigh and Joe Darion show; 1966 Tony Award for Best Musical winner |
| 28% | ASTRANGELOOP | 12 | Winner of Best Musical at the 75th Tony Awards, and the 2020 Pulitzer Prize for Drama |
| 27% | THEODD | 6 | & 21A Neil Simon stage comedy; 1965 Tony Award Best Play nominee |
| 27% | ACHORUSLINE | 11 | 1975 Broadway show; 1976 Tony Award for Best Musical winner |
| 26% | GWENVERDON | 10 | She won three Tony Awards for Best Actress in a Musical, for "Damn Yankees," "New Girl in Town," and "Redhead": 2 wds. |
| 26% | BUSSTOP | 7 | William Inge stage drama; 1956 Tony Award for Best Play nominee |
| 26% | BUS | 3 | William Inge stage drama; 1956 Tony Award for Best Play nominee |
| 26% | COMPANY | 7 | Stephen Sondheim Broadway show; 1971 Tony Award for Best Musical winner |
| 26% | ANGELALANSBURY | 14 | She won a record four Tony Awards for Best Actress in a Musical, for "Mame," "Dear World," "Gypsy," and "Sweeney Todd": 2 wds. |
| 26% | MARYMARTIN | 10 | She won three Tony Awards for Best Actress in a Musical, for "South Pacific," "Peter Pan," and "The Sound of Music": 2 wds. |
| 26% | DELATOUR | 8 | Frances —, 2006 Tony Award Best Featured Actress in a Play winner for The History Boys |
| 25% | RENT | 4 | 1996 Tony Award winner for Best Musical |
| 25% | ELTON | 5 | British musician; 2000 Tony Award Best Original Musical Score winner for Aida |