| 100% | THEPITANDTHE | 12 | & 1D 1842 short story by Edgar Allan Poe adapted for the cinema by Richard Matheson in 1961 |
| 46% | RUE | 3 | "The Murders in the ___ Morgue," short story by Edgar Allan Poe |
| 44% | FALL | 4 | "The ___ of the House of Usher," gothic short story by Edgar Allan Poe which is about two ailing siblings living in a strange mansion |
| 43% | MURDERS | 7 | "The ___ in the Rue Morgue," short story by Edgar Allan Poe which is also considered the first modern detective story |
| 43% | RUE | 3 | "The Murders in the ___ Morgue" (short story by Edgar Allan Poe) |
| 40% | THEGOLDBUG | 10 | Short story by Edgar Allan Poe first published in 1843 whose central character is William Legrand |
| 37% | ELEONORA | 8 | Autobiographical short story by Edgar Allan Poe |
| 36% | THEPREMATURE | 12 | & 15A 1844 short story by Edgar Allan Poe |
| 34% | BLACK | 5 | "The ___ Cat," gothic story by Edgar Allan Poe which follows the story of an unreliable narrator |
| 34% | USHER | 5 | "The Fall of the House of ___," gothic story by Edgar Allan Poe |
| 34% | RUE | 3 | "The Murders in the ___ Morgue" (Edgar Allan Poe short story) |
| 34% | TELLTALE | 8 | "The ___ Heart," gothic story by Edgar Allan Poe which follows the story of the narrator's hamartia: Hyph. |
| 33% | RAVEN | 5 | "The ___," gothic narrative poem by Edgar Allan Poe which follows the story of the titular talking bird |
| 30% | OBITS | 5 | Horror short story by Stephen King that was nominated for an Edgar Award in 2016 |
| 30% | THEFALLOFTHE | 12 | & 22A 1839 short story by Edgar Allen Poe |
| 29% | PIT | 3 | "The ___ and the Pendulum" (Edgar Allan Poe short story) |
| 29% | RUE | 3 | "The Murders in the ___ Morgue" (Edgar Allan Poe story) |
| 29% | RED | 3 | "The Masque of the ___ Death" (Edgar Allan Poe short story) |
| 29% | THELETTER | 9 | W Somerset Maugham short story in 1926 collection The Casuarina Tree adapted for the stage in 1927 |
| 28% | RUE | 3 | Edgar Allan Poe’s “The Murders in the ___ Morgue” |
| 28% | RUE | 3 | Edgar Allan Poe's "The Murders in the ___ Morgue" |
| 28% | RUE | 3 | Edgar Allan Poe's "The Murders in the __ Morgue" |
| 28% | ANNABEL | 7 | "___ Lee," last complete poem by Edgar Allan Poe which follows the death of a beautiful woman |
| 27% | CASK | 4 | "The ___ of Amontillado" (Edgar Allan Poe short story) |
| 27% | STATEFAIR | 9 | 1932 novel by Phil Stong adapted for the cinema and as a Broadway musical |
| 27% | GOLDBUG | 7 | Edgar Allan Poe story, with "The" |