| 100% | LONELIEST | 9 | '___ Star' (Seal song) |
| 75% | AROSE | 5 | Seal song "Kiss from ___" (2 wds.) |
| 70% | DIAMONDGIRL | 11 | Seals and Crofts song |
| 68% | SOLOMONS | 8 | ___ seal (six-pointed star) |
| 68% | SUMMERBREEZE | 12 | Seals and Crofts hit song |
| 66% | YOURETHETOP | 11 | Song mentioning all the starred answers |
| 66% | CAAN | 4 | "Brian's Song" star |
| 66% | ALI | 3 | "Swan Song" star Mahershala |
| 66% | LOST | 4 | "___ Stars," song by Adam Levine |
| 64% | DELIVERED | 9 | Stevie Wonder song, Signed, Sealed, __ |
| 64% | IMA | 3 | "Baby ___ Star" (Prince song) |
| 63% | TONIGHT | 7 | Star-crossed lovers song from West Side Story |
| 62% | BREEZE | 6 | "Summer ___," 1972 song by Seals & Crofts |
| 61% | SIGNED | 6 | "___, Sealed, Delivered, I'm Yours" (Stevie Wonder song) |
| 61% | OMYSOUL | 7 | 1974 song by rock's Big Star |
| 61% | NYC | 3 | "Annie" song that features Star-to-Be |
| 61% | OUR | 3 | "___ Lips Are Sealed" (Go-Go's song) |
| 61% | ARE | 3 | "Our Lips ___ Sealed" (Go-Go's song) |
| 61% | IMA | 3 | "Baby ___ Star" (Prince song): 2 wds. |
| 59% | EVERGREEN | 9 | Oscar-winning song from "A Star Is Born" |
| 59% | MYGUY | 5 | Biggest song for Motown's first female star |
| 59% | SIA | 3 | Australian pop star with the hit song "Chandelier" |
| 59% | BOBMARLEY | 9 | Reggae star known for "Redemption Song": 2 wds. |
| 59% | ALIBI | 5 | Bradley Cooper song in "A Star Is Born" |
| 59% | AIDA | 4 | Musical with the song "Written in the Stars" |
| 58% | AROSE | 5 | "Kiss From ___" (Grammy-winning song by Seal): 2 wds. |
| 57% | MTV | 3 | Its first song was "Video Killed the Radio Star" |
| 57% | NENA | 4 | German pop star who once had a #2 song |
| 57% | SHALLOW | 7 | Hit song from 2018's A Star Is Born |
| 57% | ILL | 3 | "___ Never Love Again," song from "A Star Is Born" |