| 100% | YOUHADTOBETHERE | 15 | *"I can't capture how amazing that was!" |
| 48% | QUOTE | 5 | "Don't ___ me on that" ("I could be wrong") |
| 47% | TOOREAL | 7 | "I don't like how lifelike that is!" (2 wds.) |
| 46% | UNSEE | 5 | “TMI! I can’t ___ that!” |
| 45% | WISH | 4 | "(___ I Could Fly Like) Superman," 1979 song by the Kinks that is inspired by Superman |
| 45% | STRENGTH | 8 | D&D score that determines how much can be carried |
| 44% | DUH | 3 | "I can't believe I missed that!" |
| 44% | MEANDMYMOUTH | 12 | "I can't believe I said that" |
| 44% | DUH | 3 | "I can't believe I missed that question!" |
| 43% | LIE | 3 | That can't be right |
| 43% | SPY | 3 | I ___, guessing game that can be played as a diversion during a road trip |
| 43% | TITANIC | 7 | I can’t - it turned out to be vast |
| 43% | DOH | 3 | "How could I do that?!" |
| 42% | DUH | 3 | "I can't believe I didn't think of that!" |
| 42% | STAND | 5 | "Ugh, I can't ___ that guy" |
| 42% | DOH | 3 | "How could I be so silly?!" |
| 42% | BRAVO | 5 | That was amazing! |
| 42% | OHNO | 4 | "I can't believe this is happening to me!": 2 wds. |
| 41% | RID | 3 | "You can't get ___ of me that easily!" |
| 41% | PFFT | 4 | "You can't expect me to believe that!" |
| 41% | SNOOTIER | 8 | How someone like Gwyneth Paltrow or Kanye West can be considered, certainly compared to lil' old me! |
| 41% | HELLNO | 6 | “How can you even ask me that!?” |
| 41% | SURE | 4 | "How Can I Be ___?" (Young Rascals hit) |
| 41% | IMHURT | 6 | "How could you think that of me?" |
| 41% | LEAR | 4 | King with the immortal line "Who is it that can tell me who I am?" |
| 41% | OMITS | 5 | Neglects to mention, as I can't seem to understand how to do |
| 41% | AWE | 3 | "I'm in ___!" ("Wow, that was amazing!") |
| 41% | ILLSTOP | 7 | "Didn't realize how annoying that was, sorry" |
| 41% | NATURE | 6 | Mother that can't be fooled |
| 41% | IMACS | 5 | Apples that can't be eaten |