| 100% | SILK | 4 | *Smooth material for a seemingly endless handkerchief that a magician might pull out from their pocket |
| 32% | RABBIT | 6 | What a magician might pull out of the [circled letters] |
| 32% | HAT | 3 | A magician might pull a rabbit out of one |
| 32% | TOPHAT | 6 | A magician might pull a rabbit out of one |
| 32% | COIN | 4 | What a magician might pull from your ear |
| 31% | HAT | 3 | What a magician might pull a rabbit out of |
| 31% | HAT | 3 | What a magician may pull a rabbit out of |
| 30% | BOOTS | 5 | "These ___ Are Made for Walkin'," Nancy Sinatra song that might pop into your head while pulling out your favorite shoes from the closet |
| 29% | INK | 3 | Liquid that may come out from a pen or a squid |
| 28% | DENIM | 5 | Material with a name that comes from a shortening of the French for "serge from Nîmes" |
| 28% | FAKEID | 6 | Something that might be nervously pulled out of a wallet |
| 27% | WEED | 4 | Plant that might be pulled from a lawn |
| 27% | COINS | 5 | *Circular pieces magicians might appear to pull out from behind people's ears |
| 27% | GETREADYWITHME | 14 | Genre of TikTok video that might be filmed while preparing for a night out |
| 27% | CHAI | 4 | Something a waiter may pull out |
| 26% | UFO | 3 | Craft from outer space that may look like a saucer: Abbr. |
| 26% | RBI | 3 | Stat that may result from a successful squeeze play, for short |
| 26% | LEG | 3 | Body part that may be "pulled" for a joke? |
| 26% | TAR | 3 | Material that a steamroller might drive over |
| 25% | ASH | 3 | Pale wood from a hardwood tree that may be used for making baseball bats |
| 25% | MACRAME | 7 | Material for a knotted wall decor that was popular in the '70s |
| 25% | REDS | 4 | M&M's that were removed from 1976 to 1987 out of a health concern for a coloring dye |
| 25% | POND | 4 | Small body of water that a frog might hang out in |
| 25% | BIBLE | 5 | Book that a priest might read from |
| 25% | NAIL | 4 | Fastener that a picture might hang from |
| 25% | BESTCASE | 8 | Scenario that a person may hope for |
| 25% | WEED | 4 | A gardener might pull one out of a flower bed |
| 25% | TAFFY | 5 | Boardwalk treat that may pull out your fillings |
| 25% | PEC | 3 | Muscle that a bodybuilder might "bounce," for short |
| 25% | PINE | 4 | Softwood from a tree with cones and needles, that may be used for making cabinets and frames |