| 100% | MELON | 5 | ___ Ball (cocktail that tastes like honeydew) |
| 54% | EMU | 3 | Poultry that tastes like beef |
| 54% | EMU | 3 | Meat that tastes like chicken |
| 54% | ANISE | 5 | Herb that tastes like licorice |
| 54% | ANISE | 5 | Flavoring that tastes like licorice |
| 54% | LICORICE | 8 | Candy that tastes like fennel |
| 54% | ANISE | 5 | Spice that tastes like licorice |
| 54% | OREOOS | 6 | Cereal that tastes like cookies |
| 53% | BEEFYVITAMINS | 13 | Dietary supplements that taste like steak? |
| 52% | WASABI | 6 | Japanese root that tastes like strong horseradish |
| 51% | FENNEL | 6 | Celery look alike veggie that tastes like licorice |
| 50% | ERIC | 4 | "Korean American: Food That Tastes Like Home" author Kim |
| 50% | FENNEL | 6 | Vegetable in the carrot family that tastes like anise |
| 47% | FROST | 5 | ___ Bites, magical candy from "The Candy Shop War" that tastes like vanilla yogurt |
| 46% | XXXX | 4 | Like a ball that hits the batter |
| 46% | UMAMI | 5 | Savory taste, like that of fish sauce |
| 46% | CLOSEST | 7 | Like the balls that score in boccie |
| 46% | ANISE | 5 | Star shaped seed that tastes like licorice which is used in Biscotti and Absinthe |
| 44% | RICH | 4 | Like a cake that isn't "poor" in taste? |
| 44% | OUTSIDE | 7 | Like some pitches that are called balls by umpires |
| 44% | HAILSTONE | 9 | Ball of ice that falls from the sky like rain |
| 44% | FAIR | 4 | Like a fly ball that hits the foul pole, ironically |
| 43% | MANHATTAN | 9 | Cocktail that Marilyn Monroe mixes in a hot water bottle in "Some Like It Hot" |
| 42% | FOWL | 4 | Birds that sound like they'd taste bad? |
| 41% | HAIL | 4 | Ice balls that fall like rain |
| 41% | HAILSTONE | 9 | Hard ball of ice that falls from the sky like rain |
| 40% | HENBIT | 6 | Common and widely distributed weed of the Lamium species that tastes a bit like peppered celery |
| 40% | MUAYTHAI | 8 | Boxing sport that sounds like a rum cocktail |
| 38% | SOUR | 4 | Tasting like lemons |
| 38% | SWEET | 5 | Tasting like honey |