| 100% | ELLIS | 5 | ___ Island (New York site where many immigrants were processed) |
| 43% | GYM | 3 | Site where many New Year's resolutions begin in earnest |
| 43% | INSET | 5 | Where many an island is found |
| 42% | ELMIRA | 6 | New York city where Mark Twain is buried |
| 42% | RYE | 3 | New York city where Ogden Nash was born |
| 42% | MANHATTAN | 9 | New York borough where Times Square is located |
| 42% | BROOKLYN | 8 | New York borough where Lil' Kim was born |
| 41% | ARMONK | 6 | New York hamlet where I.B.M. is headquartered |
| 41% | BROADWAY | 8 | New York City theater district where 28-Across is playing |
| 41% | ELMIRA | 6 | New York city where Mark Twain was married and buried |
| 40% | TUMBLR | 6 | Short-form blogging site where many 10-Across are responded to with GIFs |
| 40% | NYACK | 5 | New York village where Edward Hopper and Helen Hayes are buried |
| 39% | ELLIS | 5 | Samuel for whom a New York Harbor island is named |
| 39% | MAINE | 5 | New England state where many Stephen King novels are set |
| 39% | TOKELAU | 7 | New Zealand island group where copra is produced |
| 39% | WEST | 4 | New York-to-California direction (and where this answer is in the diagram) |
| 39% | ELMIRA | 6 | Upstate New York city where Mark Twain was born |
| 39% | ELMIRA | 6 | Upstate New York city where Mark Twain was buried |
| 39% | THECATSKILLS | 12 | Upstate New York area where 63-Across was held |
| 38% | ENDICOTT | 8 | Upstate New York town where I.B.M. was founded |
| 38% | USA | 3 | Country where New York is: Abbr. |
| 37% | PARK | 4 | Central ___, New York City landmark that is the most filmed location in the world |
| 37% | OAHU | 4 | Hawaiian island where most of "Lost" was filmed |
| 36% | OAHU | 4 | Hawaiian island where most NFL Pro Bowls were played |
| 35% | KATZ | 4 | New York deli where the "I'll have what she's having" scene in "When Harry Met Sally ..." was filmed |
| 35% | ELLIS | 5 | ___ Island, immigration site in New York Harbor |
| 35% | TOM | 3 | ___ Gola, former New York Knicks player who is among those with the most triple-doubles in NBA history |
| 35% | EAST | 4 | ___ Coast (where New York City is) |
| 35% | STATEN | 6 | New York island |
| 35% | ELLIS | 5 | New York island |