| 100% | JACK | 4 | ___ o'lantern, fall staple that would butter you up with "You make me light up!" |
| 67% | CROW | 4 | Word after "scare" to refer to a fall staple that would butter you up with "You got me standing tall!" |
| 64% | CORN | 4 | Fall staple that would butter you up with "I'm all ears for you!" |
| 62% | LEAVES | 6 | Fall's colorful staple that would butter you up with "I keep falling for you!" |
| 45% | BONFIRE | 7 | Cozy fall night favorite that would warm you up with "I feel a spark between us!" |
| 42% | SWEATER | 7 | Autumn attire that would sweet-talk you with "You make me feel warm" |
| 34% | LETYOUBERIGHT | 13 | Hit single by 9-Down with the lyric "We can make up if you just kiss me at the next traffic light" (4 wds.) |
| 31% | NOSE | 4 | Body part that lights up when you make a mistake in the board game Operation |
| 30% | ALFREDO | 7 | What would you call a fettuccine dish made with parmesan and butter? |
| 29% | THEMAN | 6 | Taylor Swift song with the lyric "Every conquest I had made would make me more of a boss to you" |
| 29% | POISONPENNE | 11 | Pasta that will make you really sick? |
| 28% | FATHERTIME | 10 | "___? That's when you're hanging out with me" |
| 28% | CUES | 4 | Gizmos that will help you with your banking |
| 27% | EVILWOMAN | 9 | 1975 Electric Light Orchestra hit that begins "You made a fool of me" |
| 27% | IRA | 3 | Item that will cost you if you make an early withdrawal |
| 27% | THEMOSQUITOASCOT | 16 | Fashion book that will make you look like a million bugs? |
| 27% | SEE | 3 | "Didn't I tell you that would happen?" |
| 27% | DONTTEMPTME | 11 | "Careful — I might take you up on that" |
| 27% | LET | 3 | "___ me help you with that" |
| 26% | CUT | 3 | Paper ___, a tiny but surprisingly painful injury that would make you say "ouch" |
| 26% | DIDIASK | 7 | "Interesting that you think that would matter to me" |
| 26% | AWL | 3 | Something that will really help you make a point |
| 26% | USA | 3 | The land that was made for you and me |
| 26% | POTION | 6 | Will magically make you fall in love |
| 26% | HYDROGEN | 8 | Lightest element, makes up water with oxygen |
| 26% | BLACKDOG | 8 | 52-Across song with the lyrics "At least I know that you are trying / But that's what makes it terrifying" (2 wds.) |
| 26% | BODYGUARD | 9 | The __, film with Whitney's I Will Always Love You |
| 26% | ABCS | 4 | Song that ends "Next time won't you sing with me" |
| 25% | YES | 3 | "Is that a ___?" ("Are you with me on this?") |
| 25% | IBID | 4 | Abbr. that may make you look up |