| 100% | ROSS | 4 | ___ Ohlendorf, former baseball player for the Pittsburgh Pirates who attended Princeton University |
| 61% | EDDIE | 5 | ___ Collins, former baseball player for the Philadelphia Athletics who attended Columbia University |
| 60% | LOU | 3 | ___ Gehrig, former baseball player for the New York Yankees who attended Columbia University |
| 53% | RED | 3 | ___ Rolfe, former baseball player for the New York Yankees who attended Dartmouth College |
| 51% | MATTHEW | 7 | ___ Bowman, baseball pitcher for the Cincinnati Reds who attended Princeton University |
| 42% | SOSA | 4 | Former baseball player Sammy who was known for his home-run hitting skills in the '90s |
| 41% | GIL | 3 | ___ Hodges, former baseball player for the Dodgers |
| 41% | ROBERTO | 7 | ___ Clemente, Puerto Rican baseball player who played 18 seasons for the Pittsburgh Pirates |
| 35% | AROD | 4 | Nickname of former professional baseball player for the Yankees |
| 34% | TROUT | 5 | Mike ___, baseball player who has played for the Los Angeles Angels since 2011 |
| 34% | HENDRICKS | 9 | Kyle ___, baseball pitcher for the Chicago Cubs who attended Dartmouth College |
| 34% | ROSE | 4 | Pete ___, former baseball player who is the all-time MLB leader in hits and number of games played |
| 33% | DANMARINO | 9 | Pennsylvania-born Football Hall of Famer who attended the University of Pittsburgh: 2 wds. |
| 33% | MIKEDITKA | 9 | Pennsylvania-born Football Hall of Famer who attended the University of Pittsburgh: 2 wds. |
| 33% | JOHNSON | 7 | Walter ___, American baseball player who played his 21-year career for the Washington Senators |
| 33% | BERRA | 5 | Yogi —, baseball player who appeared in fourteen World Series for the New York Yankees |
| 33% | WALTERPAYTON | 12 | Former NFL player for the Chicago Bears, known as "Sweetness," who is considered one of the greatest RBs ever: 2 wds. |
| 33% | CURTIS | 6 | With 35-Across, Pennsylvania-born Football Hall of Famer who attended the University of Pittsburgh |
| 33% | PNC | 3 | ___ Park, home for the Pittsburgh Pirates |
| 33% | TED | 3 | ___ Williams, American baseball player who played his 19-year career for the Boston Red Sox |
| 33% | STAN | 4 | ___ Musial, American baseball player who played his 22-year career for the St. Louis Cardinals |
| 33% | MICKEY | 6 | ___ Mantle, American baseball player who played his 18-year career for the New York Yankees |
| 33% | BABE | 4 | ___ Ruth, former baseball player who once said, "Never let the fear of striking out keep you from playing the game" |
| 33% | PETEROSE | 8 | Former Reds player who's banned from the Baseball Hall of Fame: 2 wds. |
| 32% | WARD | 4 | Charlie ___, former basketball player for the New York Knicks who was also an exceptional football player |
| 31% | JASONKIDD | 9 | Former Knicks player who holds the record for second most number of assists in NBA: 2 wds. |
| 31% | JOHNSTOCKTON | 12 | Former Utah Jazz player who holds the record for most number of assists in NBA: 2 wds. |
| 31% | STEVENASH | 9 | Former Lakers player who holds the record for third most number of assists in NBA: 2 wds. |
| 31% | KAREEM | 6 | ___ Abdul- Jabbar, former basketballer who holds the record for most NBA wins by a player |
| 31% | LEEMAYE | 7 | Former MLB player who was also the lead singer for an LA-based doo-wop group: 2 wds. |