| 100% | PUERTO | 6 | ___ Rico: Island in the Caribbean sea, southeast of Miami-Florida |
| 60% | ISLEOF | 6 | & 13A Island in the Caribbean Sea off SW Cuba formerly called the Isle of Pines |
| 56% | ORANJESTAD | 10 | Capital of island Aruba in the Caribbean Sea |
| 55% | ARUBA | 5 | Dutch island in the Caribbean Sea |
| 54% | YOUTH | 5 | Isle of —, island in the Caribbean Sea off SW Cuba formerly called the Isle of Pines |
| 53% | PUERTO | 6 | Independent nation in the Caribbean Sea: ___ Rico |
| 50% | TORTUGA | 7 | Island in the Caribbean, formerly a haunt of pirates, off the NW coast of Haiti |
| 48% | ISCHIA | 6 | Island in the Tyrrhenian Sea at the entrance to the Bay of Naples |
| 48% | CORFU | 5 | Island in the Ionian Sea forming part of a regional unit of Greece |
| 48% | GRENADA | 7 | Island country in the Caribbean Sea whose capital is St George’s |
| 47% | CYCLADES | 8 | Group of islands in the Aegean Sea including Anafi |
| 46% | ANTILLES | 8 | Group of islands in the Caribbean consisting of the Greater — and Lesser — |
| 46% | ISLE | 4 | ___ of Man, island in the Irish Sea |
| 46% | DODECANESE | 10 | Group of islands in the Aegean Sea whose capital is Rhodes |
| 46% | CARIBBEAN | 9 | Sea in which the island of Cozumel is located |
| 46% | CARIBBEAN | 9 | Sea in which the island of Redonda is found |
| 46% | AMELIA | 6 | Southernmost of the Southeast's Sea Islands |
| 45% | MARACAIBO | 9 | Large inlet of the Caribbean Sea in Venezuela |
| 45% | JAMAICA | 7 | Island in the Caribbean; capital Kingston |
| 45% | PONCE | 5 | Caribbean port; second largest city on the island of Puerto Rico |
| 44% | ERITREA | 7 | Country with hundreds of islands in the Red Sea |
| 44% | INDIES | 6 | West __, most of the islands in the Caribbean |
| 44% | ISLE | 4 | ___ of Man, small island in the Irish sea |
| 44% | ARUBA | 5 | Dutch island in the Caribbean |
| 44% | CUBA | 4 | Largest island in the Caribbean |
| 44% | ANTIGUA | 7 | Island in the Caribbean linked administratively with Barbuda |
| 44% | TOBAGO | 6 | English-speaking island in the Caribbean |
| 44% | JAMAICA | 7 | Third-largest island in the Caribbean |
| 44% | SAMOTHRACE | 10 | Largely mountainous island in the Aegean Sea; an important centre of worship in ancient times |
| 44% | LAVA | 4 | What erupted from a volcano on the Caribbean island of St. Vincent starting in April |