| 100% | HATE | 4 | ___ Story (if Taylor Swift's "Love Story" was about someone she intensely disliked?) |
| 49% | WARM | 4 | ___ As Me (if Taylor Swift's "Cold as You" was about her feeling hot on a summer day?) |
| 45% | END | 3 | ___ Once (if Taylor Swift's "Begin Again" was about finishing something?) |
| 43% | STYLE | 5 | 2014 song from Taylor Swift's "1989" album rumored to be about her romance with Harry Styles |
| 39% | DEAR | 4 | "___ John," 2010 song by Taylor Swift rumored to be about her romance with John Mayer |
| 38% | BACK | 4 | "___ to December," 2010 song by Taylor Swift rumored to be about her romance with Taylor Lautner |
| 38% | ALL | 3 | "___ Too Well," 2012 song by Taylor Swift rumored to be about her romance with Jake Gyllenhaal |
| 38% | ROMEO | 5 | Shakespearean character mentioned in Taylor Swift's "Love Story" |
| 38% | ROMEO | 5 | Character name-checked on Taylor Swift's "Love Story" |
| 38% | ROMEO | 5 | Shakespeare character mentioned in Taylor Swift's "Love Story" |
| 37% | ROMEO | 5 | Shakespeare character in the lyrics of Taylor Swift's "Love Story" |
| 36% | OUTOFTHEWOODS | 13 | Song from Taylor Swift's "1989" that is rumored to be about Harry Styles: 4 wds. |
| 36% | SAYYES | 6 | "You'll be the prince and I'll be the princess / It's a love story, baby, just ___ ... " (Taylor Swift lyric) |
| 34% | BIOGRAPHY | 9 | Story written about someone's life |
| 34% | LOVE | 4 | Taylor Swift’s “___ Story” |
| 33% | RED | 3 | Taylor Swift's album that is a primary color |
| 33% | KNEW | 4 | Taylor Swift's "I ___ You Were Trouble" |
| 33% | AREIN | 5 | Taylor Swift’s “You ___ Love” |
| 33% | EVER | 4 | Taylor Swift's song "We Are Never ___ Getting Back Together" |
| 33% | ARE | 3 | Taylor Swift's "You ___ in Love" |
| 33% | THIS | 4 | Taylor Swift's "__ Is Me Trying" |
| 32% | FIFTEEN | 7 | 2008 Taylor Swift song about being a freshman in high school |
| 32% | ROMANCE | 7 | Genre of film or book that is about a love story |
| 32% | SAYYES | 6 | "It's a love story, baby, just ___ ... " (Taylor Swift lyric) (2 wds.) |
| 32% | ALI | 3 | She's Jenny in Love Story |
| 31% | MEAN | 4 | Taylor Swift's hit song directed at her critics |
| 31% | HAD | 3 | Taylor Swift's "All You ___ To Do Was Stay" |
| 31% | EVER | 4 | Taylor Swift's "We Are Never ___ Getting Back Together" |
| 31% | ERA | 3 | TTPD is Taylor Swift's latest one |
| 31% | TIM | 3 | "___ McGraw," 2006 song by Taylor Swift about the "Live Like You Were Dying" singer |