| 100% | HONUS | 5 | ___ Wagner, player on an ultrarare baseball card |
| 47% | ASTRO | 5 | Baseball player with an H on his cap |
| 46% | HONUS | 5 | Wagner on a very valuable baseball card |
| 40% | VOTE | 4 | Pick players on an All-Star ballot, say |
| 40% | ELEVEN | 6 | Number of players on an American football team |
| 40% | FIVE | 4 | Number of players on an NBA starting lineup |
| 40% | CUE | 3 | Message on an offstage card |
| 40% | SKIP | 4 | Verb on an Uno card |
| 39% | ISOTOPE | 7 | Player on Springfield's minor league baseball team |
| 39% | INFIELDER | 9 | Defensive player on a baseball diamond |
| 39% | HITTERS | 7 | Baseball players on offense |
| 38% | MET | 3 | Player on New York's National League baseball team |
| 38% | NAT | 3 | Player on a D.C. baseball team, for short |
| 38% | LACE | 4 | String on an hockey player's skate |
| 38% | NINE | 4 | Number of players on a baseball team |
| 37% | MTA | 3 | Letters on an N.Y.C. fare card |
| 37% | NINE | 4 | Number of players on a side in baseball |
| 37% | HALO | 4 | Symbol on an Angels baseball cap |
| 37% | STAT | 4 | Number on an athlete's trading card, for short |
| 37% | PITCHERS | 8 | Baseball players who stand on the mound |
| 37% | CAPS | 4 | Baseball players wear them on their heads |
| 36% | BABERUTH | 8 | Player's autograph on baseball in The Sandlot |
| 36% | UNO | 3 | Card game with an edition for colorblind players |
| 36% | POKERFACE | 9 | Expression of an experienced card player |
| 36% | FOOL | 4 | Character on an unnumbered tarot card |
| 36% | STATS | 5 | Numbers on baseball cards |
| 35% | HOMERUN | 7 | Baseball player rounds all bases on a single hit |
| 35% | HONUS | 5 | Wagner whose baseball card sells for millions |
| 35% | CLEAT | 5 | Spike on a baseball player's shoe |
| 35% | CAP | 3 | Found on a baseball player's head |