| 100% | GLO | 3 | ___ Worm, '80s battery-operated stuffed toy that lights up when squeezed |
| 74% | GLO | 3 | ___ Worm (stuffed toy that lights up when squeezed) |
| 49% | GLO | 3 | ___ Worm (stuffed Playskool toy that lights up) |
| 37% | NOSE | 4 | Body part that lights up when you make a mistake in the board game Operation |
| 36% | FLARE | 5 | Light that goes up when things are going down? |
| 32% | GLO | 3 | ___ Worm (light-up stuffed toy) |
| 31% | GLO | 3 | ___ Worm (1980s light-up toy) |
| 31% | NOSE | 4 | Rudolph feature that lights up |
| 31% | FIREFLIES | 9 | Insects that light up at night |
| 30% | ARGON | 5 | It lights up when it's excited |
| 30% | NEON | 4 | Signs that light up in the dark? |
| 30% | FIREWORKS | 9 | Rockets that light up the sky in celebrations |
| 30% | YOYO | 4 | Toy that goes up and down |
| 29% | SEATBELT | 8 | Icon that lights up during a turbulent plane ride |
| 29% | BABY | 4 | Beanie ___, iconic '90s stuffed toy that became a fad |
| 29% | YOYO | 4 | Toy that goes up and down: Hyph. |
| 29% | YOYOS | 5 | Toys that go up and down: Hyph. |
| 29% | YOYOS | 5 | Toys that have their ups and downs |
| 28% | FIREFLY | 7 | Insect that lights up ... or something that flickers in the night |
| 28% | LUMOS | 5 | Magical spell in "Harry Potter" that lights up one's wand |
| 28% | LEGO | 4 | Toy that hurts when you step on it barefoot |
| 28% | YOYO | 4 | Toy that goes up and down on a string |
| 28% | SLED | 4 | Toy that goes up slow and comes down fast |
| 28% | YOYO | 4 | Toy that a person moves up and down: Hyph. |
| 28% | YOYO | 4 | Toy that goes up and down on a string: Hyph. |
| 27% | PUFFER | 6 | Fish that blows up when threatened |
| 27% | POPCORN | 7 | Kernels that puff up when heated |
| 27% | RATTLE | 6 | Baby's toy that makes a noise when shaken |
| 27% | PINWHEEL | 8 | Child's fan-like toy that spins when blown |
| 27% | DUST | 4 | Stuff that gradually builds up on furniture |