| 100% | SHAPEOF | 7 | __ You; huge hit for Ed Sheeran in 2017 |
| 75% | ONTHEHILL | 9 | Castle __, hit for Ed Sheeran in 2017 |
| 62% | BADHABITS | 9 | Top Ten hit for Ed Sheeran in 2021 |
| 57% | SHAPEOFYOU | 10 | 2017 Ed Sheeran hit that spent 33 weeks in the Top 10, tied for the record: 3 wds. |
| 51% | COMEAS | 6 | __ You Are; huge hit for Nirvana in 1992 |
| 50% | PERFECT | 7 | 2017 top 10 hit for Ed Sheeran, or a 2015 top 10 hit for One Direction |
| 46% | SHAPE | 5 | Ed Sheeran hit "___ of You" |
| 43% | THEHILL | 7 | Castle On __; Ed Sheeran hit song from 2017 |
| 41% | PERFECT | 7 | 2017 Ed Sheeran #1 hit with a Beyoncé remix |
| 41% | ROCKIN | 6 | __ Robin; huge hit for Michael Jackson in 1972 |
| 41% | CHASING | 7 | __ Cars; huge hit for Snow Patrol in 2006 |
| 40% | SHEERAN | 7 | Ed with the 2017 #1 hit "Shape of You" |
| 38% | ALBUM | 5 | "+" or "÷," for Ed Sheeran |
| 37% | CHAKAKHAN | 9 | Singer in Rufus whose solo hits include "I Feel for You": 2 wds. |
| 37% | CARE | 4 | "I Don't ___," song by Ed Sheeran and Justin Bieber which was nominated for a Brit Award in 2020 |
| 36% | REDHEAD | 7 | Ed sheeran, for one |
| 36% | BECRUEL | 7 | Don't __; 1956 huge hit for Elvis |
| 36% | SHAPE | 5 | Ed Sheeran's "___ of You" |
| 36% | LITTLELIES | 10 | Fleetwood Mac hit with the lyric "I'll settle for one day to believe in you" |
| 35% | BOHEMIAN | 8 | This rhapsody was a huge hit for Queen |
| 35% | NOONE | 5 | Who can get in the way of what Alicia Keys feels for you, in a 2007 hit |
| 35% | SUBTRACT | 8 | Ed Sheeran album released in 2023 |
| 35% | SING | 4 | 2014 Ed Sheeran hit |
| 35% | PHOTOGRAPH | 10 | 2015 Ed Sheeran hit |
| 35% | GTO | 3 | Car for which you "Listen to her tachin' up now, listen to her whine," in a 1964 hit |
| 34% | HABITS | 6 | "Bad ___" (2021 Ed Sheeran hit) |
| 34% | NOONE | 5 | Who "can get in the way of what I feel for you," in a 2007 #1 Alicia Keys hit |
| 34% | BELIEVE | 7 | "I ___ in You," hit song by Australian singer Kylie Minogue which was nominated for a Grammy Award in 2006 |
| 34% | SHAPE | 5 | "___ of You," 2017 Grammy-winning song by Ed Sheeran that was originally written for Rihanna |
| 34% | HAPPIER | 7 | 2017 Ed Sheeran song |