| 100% | LEOI | 4 | “Great” Pope who allegedly persuaded Attila the Hun not to invade Rome |
| 70% | STLEO | 5 | Pope who persuaded Attila the Hun not to attack Rome |
| 48% | LEOI | 4 | Pope who persuaded Attila not to attack Rome |
| 46% | STLEO | 5 | Canonized pope who persuaded Attila not to attack Rome |
| 42% | STLEO | 5 | Pope who dissuaded Attila the Hun from attacking Rome |
| 40% | STLEO | 5 | Pope who negotiated with Attila the Hun |
| 36% | LEOI | 4 | Pope who met Attila the Hun |
| 35% | SAINTLEO | 8 | Fifth-century pope who was the first to be called "the Great" |
| 35% | LEOI | 4 | Sainted fifth-century pope who met with Attila the Hun |
| 29% | STLEO | 5 | Pope who convinced Attila to turn back his invasion of Italy |
| 29% | STLEO | 5 | Canonized pope who kept 26-Across from invading Rome |
| 28% | STLEO | 5 | Religious leader who met with Attila the Hun |
| 28% | ATTILA | 6 | King of the Huns who attempted to conquer Roman Gaul in 451 |
| 27% | LEOI | 4 | Earliest pope to receive the title "the Great" |
| 27% | VOLTAIRE | 8 | To whom the saying "Common sense is not so common" is attributed |
| 27% | LATECOMER | 9 | Person who did not get to the party on time |
| 26% | STLEO | 5 | Fifth-century pope, the first to receive the title "the Great" |
| 26% | ASOCIAL | 7 | Like one who's not inclined to mingle with the crowd |
| 26% | ASH | 3 | Ketchum who wants to be the world's greatest Pokémon Master |
| 26% | PIUSII | 6 | 15th-century pontiff who was the only pope to write an autobiography |
| 26% | MOM | 3 | One who tells you to not roll around in the dirt, maybe |
| 25% | BARBARIC | 8 | Like Attila the Hun |
| 25% | AAMILNE | 7 | Who wrote "Some people talk to animals. Not many listen, though. That's the problem." |
| 25% | ARISTOTLE | 9 | Plato's pupil who went on to be Alexander the Great's tutor |
| 25% | BASIE | 5 | Jazz great who was the first African-American man to win a Grammy |
| 25% | LAOCOON | 7 | Priest who warned the Trojans not to accept the wooden horse |
| 25% | DRED | 4 | ___ Scott, who the Supreme Court said was not free to sue for his freedom |
| 25% | STLEO | 5 | A famous religious leader who met with Attila the Hun: 2 wds |
| 25% | CDVI | 4 | Year Attila the Hun was born |
| 25% | STEFANEDBERG | 12 | Swedish tennis great who lost to 25-Across in the 1990 Australian Open (2 wds.) |