| 100% | IHAD | 4 | “If ___ a nickel for ...” |
| 92% | IHAD | 4 | "If ___ a nickel for every time ...": 2 wds. |
| 92% | IHAD | 4 | "If ___ a nickel for every time...": 2 wds. |
| 86% | HAD | 3 | "If I ___ a nickel for every time ..." |
| 86% | HAD | 3 | "If I ___ a nickel for every time . . ." |
| 86% | HAD | 3 | "If I ___ a nickel for every time ... " |
| 69% | IHAD | 4 | "If ___ a nickel..." |
| 69% | IHAD | 4 | "If ___ a nickel …" |
| 67% | COIN | 4 | Nickel or a dime, for one |
| 66% | CENT | 4 | Change for a nickel |
| 64% | TPED | 4 | Dressed for Halloween, if you're a tree |
| 63% | OMA | 3 | Affectionate term for a grandmother, if you're German |
| 61% | FACEVALUE | 9 | Five cents, for a nickel |
| 60% | SECS | 4 | What you get if you break a minute down, for short |
| 60% | UNLESS | 6 | "___ it rains, we'll go for a picnic tomorrow" (except if) |
| 60% | ANEW | 4 | Once more as if for the first time, a fresh go |
| 60% | HADA | 4 | "If I ___ nickel for every time ...": 2 wds. |
| 59% | IHAD | 4 | "If ___ a dollar for ..." |
| 58% | GRAM | 4 | One of five for a nickel |
| 58% | ATTACKWITHAPAW | 14 | The clue for 127-Across, if this shell game weren't a scam |
| 58% | ARCTICEXPLORER | 14 | The clue for 128-Down, if this shell game weren't a scam |
| 57% | COIN | 4 | A nickel |
| 57% | IQTEST | 6 | If you happen to score 163 on this, you're immediately qualified for a Mensa membership |
| 56% | ATBAT | 5 | You don't get credit for this if you're hit by a pitch |
| 56% | RARE | 4 | Like a 1913 Liberty Head V Nickel, for example |
| 56% | PEPSI | 5 | "Twice as much for a nickel" sloganeer, once |
| 55% | OBAMA | 5 | "I would have voted for ___ for a third term if I could" ("Get Out" line) |
| 55% | YOUDONTNEEDTOKNOWTHIS | 21 | "If I could digress for a moment …" |
| 55% | DESK | 4 | Item you could buy for your residence if you happen to be a crossword creator |
| 55% | IHAD | 4 | "If___a nickel..." |