| 100% | HATTER | 6 | “Mad” Carroll character |
| 79% | ALI | 3 | Carroll character |
| 79% | ALICE | 5 | Carroll character |
| 73% | WHITERABBIT | 11 | Carroll character who was late |
| 73% | HATTER | 6 | Mad ___ (Wonderland character) |
| 71% | MAD | 3 | ___ Hatter (Lewis Carroll character) |
| 71% | MAD | 3 | ___ Hatter, Lewis Carroll character |
| 70% | MAD | 3 | The ___ Hatter (Lewis Carroll character) |
| 68% | ALICE | 5 | Carroll character played by Mia Wasikowska in 2010 |
| 68% | WHITERABBIT | 11 | Lewis Carroll character who's late |
| 67% | IRA | 3 | Mad About You character |
| 66% | CHESHIRECAT | 11 | Lewis Carroll character with a disembodied smile |
| 66% | MARCHHARE | 9 | Character in Lewis Carroll book Alice's Adventures in Wonderland depicted at the Hatter’s mad tea-party with straw on his head |
| 64% | ALICE | 5 | Lewis Carroll title character |
| 63% | MAD | 3 | ___ Hatter, DC supervillain inspired by a Lewis Carroll character |
| 62% | HATTER | 6 | Mad ___, "Alice's Adventures in Wonderland" character |
| 62% | CHESHIRECAT | 11 | Lewis Carroll's smiling character |
| 61% | OPHELIA | 7 | Character who went mad in Shakespeare's Hamlet |
| 59% | ALICE | 5 | Character who's told "We're all mad here" |
| 59% | COMMAS | 6 | Characters in "It's a Mad, Mad, Mad, Mad World" |
| 58% | MOCK | 4 | ___ Turtle (Carroll character) |
| 58% | HARE | 4 | March ___ (Carroll character) |
| 57% | MARCHHARE | 9 | As mad as a __, a Lewis Carroll description |
| 57% | DONDRAPER | 9 | Mad Men character who made the finale's Coke ad |
| 57% | MAX | 3 | Mad ___ (movie character played by Mel Gibson and Tom Hardy) |
| 57% | EMS | 3 | Lead characters in Mad Max and Magic Mike? |
| 55% | MADEA | 5 | Lead character in “Diary of a Mad Black Woman” |
| 55% | HATTER | 6 | The Mad ___, character in "Alice's Adventures in Wonderland" |
| 54% | MADHATTER | 9 | Lewis Carroll character who asks "Does your watch tell you what year it is?" |
| 54% | ALICE | 5 | Character who has tea with the Mad Hatter and the Cheshire Cat |