| 100% | ALONG | 5 | “Merrily We Roll ___” (Sondheim musical with a 2023 Broadway revival) |
| 47% | ALONG | 5 | "Merrily We Roll ___" (Sondheim musical) |
| 44% | MAME | 4 | Broadway musical with the song "We Need a Little Christmas" |
| 44% | CATS | 4 | Broadway musical with a feline name |
| 39% | PARADE | 6 | 2023 Tony winner for Best Revival of a Musical |
| 39% | ABBA | 4 | Pop group with a hit Broadway musical |
| 38% | HELLODOLLY | 10 | Broadway musical with the song "It Takes a Woman" (2 wds.) |
| 37% | BAD | 3 | "___ Cinderella" (Webber musical with a gay-us machina, per Variety) |
| 36% | NASH | 4 | He wrote a hit Broadway musical with Weill |
| 36% | CHICAGO | 7 | Musical with a "Cell Block Tango" |
| 36% | ANNIE | 5 | Musical with a preteen title character |
| 35% | DIETZ | 5 | Howard —, US lyricist of Broadway musicals Jennie, Revenge with Music and The Gay Life |
| 35% | HELLODOLLY | 10 | 2017 Broadway revival for which 41-Across won a Tony Award for Best Actress in a Musical (2 wds) |
| 34% | CATS | 4 | Movie musical with a notorious "butthole cut" |
| 34% | FROGS | 5 | 2004 Sondheim musical, with "The" |
| 34% | SHUCKED | 7 | 2023 Broadway musical about corn |
| 34% | SPAMALOT | 8 | Musical with a cow that's catapulted over a castle |
| 34% | BYJEEVES | 8 | Lloyd Webber musical with a PG Wodehouse character |
| 34% | CATS | 4 | 2019 movie musical with a tailed Taylor Swift |
| 33% | CHICAGO | 7 | 1996 Tony-winning musical revival with the song "All That Jazz" currently playing at Broadway's Ambassador Theatre |
| 33% | WIZ | 3 | 1975 musical with a Yellow Brick Road, with "The" |
| 33% | EILEEN | 6 | 2015 Ottessa Moshfegh novel with a 2023 film adaptation |
| 33% | THEKINGANDI | 11 | Musical with the song "Shall We Dance?" |
| 33% | TADA | 4 | Exclamation with a drum roll |
| 33% | TPS | 3 | Pranks with a roll, briefly |
| 33% | KAISER | 6 | Ruler with a namesake roll |
| 33% | CODA | 4 | Fish with a musical tail |
| 33% | SONGBIRD | 8 | Avian with a musical call |
| 33% | COMPANY | 7 | Stephen Sondheim musical with the song "The Ladies Who Lunch" |
| 33% | ASSASSINS | 9 | Stephen Sondheim musical with the song “The Ballad of Booth” |