| 100% | ALOOP | 5 | “You threw me for ___!” (“I was surprised!”) |
| 66% | IMEASY | 6 | "No matter what you choose for me is fine" |
| 65% | ALL | 3 | "___ I Want for Christmas Is You" |
| 64% | WANT | 4 | Mariah Carey's "All I ___ for Christmas Is You" |
| 64% | WANT | 4 | "All I ___ for Christmas Is You" (Mariah Carey song) |
| 63% | HEREIAM | 7 | "I heard you were looking for me!" (3 wds.) |
| 63% | ALL | 3 | "___ I Want for Christmas Is You" (Mariah Carey song) |
| 63% | MARIAHCAREY | 11 | "All I Want for Christmas Is You" singer |
| 62% | ALOOP | 5 | You might be thrown for it |
| 62% | CAREY | 5 | Singer of All I want for Christmas is You |
| 62% | ALL | 3 | Mariah Carey's "___ I Want for Christmas Is You" |
| 62% | USA | 3 | The land that was made for you and me |
| 62% | CAREY | 5 | "All I Want for Christmas Is You" singer Mariah |
| 61% | THREW | 5 | "That really ___ me for a loop!" ("It was so surprising!") |
| 61% | CAREY | 5 | Mariah ___, singer of "All I Want for Christmas Is You" |
| 61% | ARE | 3 | "( ___ You) The One That I've Been Waiting For" |
| 61% | ELSE | 4 | Is there anything ___ I can do for you? |
| 60% | ABEER | 5 | “Will you join me for ___?” (happy hour invitation) |
| 59% | GRANDMA | 7 | I am the relative who bakes cookies and knits sweaters for you. Who am I? |
| 58% | ALL | 3 | (8/8) "...Make my wish come true, ___ I want for Christmas is you." |
| 58% | MEANT | 5 | "You Were ___ for Me" (Jewel song) |
| 58% | JEWEL | 5 | "You Were Meant for Me" singer |
| 58% | JEWEL | 5 | *"You Were Meant for Me" singer |
| 58% | WAITING | 7 | "I Knew You Were ___ For Me," 1987 romantic duet by Aretha Franklin and George Michael |
| 57% | DOA | 3 | "Will you ___ favor for me?": 2 wds. |
| 57% | MEANT | 5 | "You Were ___ for Me" (Jewel hit song) |
| 57% | DEC | 3 | Month when all retail stores play "All I Want for Christmas Is You," for short |
| 56% | WOW | 3 | Expression of surprise for when you are in awe of something |
| 56% | IRIS | 4 | Hit song for the Goo Goo Dolls with the repeated line "I just want you to know who I am" |
| 55% | CROWNJEWEL | 10 | Conk the "You Were Meant for Me" singer? |