| 100% | BERRA | 5 | 18-time All-Star catcher |
| 85% | BENITO | 6 | Five-time All Star catcher Santiago |
| 73% | CAREW | 5 | All-Star 18 consecutive times from 1967 to 1984 |
| 73% | BERRA | 5 | 18-time all-star Yogi |
| 68% | BRYANT | 6 | 18-time NBA All-Star |
| 66% | ROD | 3 | 18-time MLB All-Star Carew |
| 66% | KOBE | 4 | 18-time NBA All-Star Bryant |
| 66% | BRYANT | 6 | 18-time nba all-star kobe |
| 66% | YOGI | 4 | 18-time MLB All-Star Berra |
| 60% | POSEY | 5 | Six-time MLB All-Star catcher Buster |
| 60% | POSEY | 5 | Seven-time MLB All-Star catcher Buster |
| 60% | KOBEBRYANT | 10 | 18-time All-Star for the LA Lakers who died on 1/26/20: 2 wds. |
| 60% | BENCH | 5 | Reds' 14x all-star catcher |
| 59% | IVANRODRIGUEZ | 13 | 14-time All-Star catcher born in Puerto Rico (his nickname is "Pudge"): 2 wds. |
| 59% | KOBE | 4 | 4-time all star mvp bryant |
| 57% | SOTO | 4 | All-Star Cubs catcher Geovany |
| 57% | PENA | 4 | 1980s All-Star catcher Tony |
| 57% | BOGART | 6 | American Film Institute's "greatest male star of all time" |
| 54% | MIKEPIAZZA | 10 | All-Star Mets catcher of the 1990s-2000s |
| 52% | DAYANDNIGHT | 11 | All the time, as well as a hint to the abbreviations hidden in the starred answers |
| 51% | PAULGOLDSCHMIDT | 15 | Six-time All-Star for the Arizona Diamondbacks (2013-18) |
| 50% | TODDHELTON | 10 | Five-time All Star, four-time Silver Slugger, and three-time Golden glove winner |
| 49% | CHUCK | 5 | ___ Taylor All Stars |
| 48% | JOHNNYBENCH | 11 | Reds catcher who was a 10-time All-Star in the 1970s: 2 wds. |
| 48% | THURMANMUNSON | 13 | Yankees catcher who was a 7-time All-Star in the 1970s: 2 wds. |
| 48% | ETERNITY | 8 | All time |
| 47% | TONY | 4 | ___ Lucca, "Right On Time" singer who starred in the variety TV show "The All New Mickey Mouse Club" |
| 47% | TINO | 4 | Two-time All-Star Martinez |
| 47% | SOSA | 4 | Seven-time All-Star Sammy |
| 47% | ALEX | 4 | 14-time All-Star Rodriguez |