| 100% | BALTO | 5 | 1920s sled dog honored with a statue in New York City's Central Park |
| 68% | BALTO | 5 | Sled dog with a statue in New York's Central Park |
| 58% | USSMAINE | 8 | Ship with a memorial in New York City's Central Park |
| 51% | BALTO | 5 | Sled dog with a statue in Central Park |
| 41% | RYE | 3 | New York city with an amusement park that's a National Historic Landmark |
| 39% | MARIOCUOMO | 10 | Former governor with a New York City bridge named in his honor: 2 wds. |
| 38% | MACYS | 5 | Department store in New York City associated with a famous Thanksgiving Day parade |
| 36% | UTICA | 5 | Ancient North African city with a namesake in New York State |
| 36% | LIBERTY | 7 | Giant green statue in New York City |
| 35% | ICERINK | 7 | Winter installation in New York's Central Park |
| 35% | LAKE | 4 | Artificial feature in New York's Central Park |
| 35% | ALHIRT | 6 | Trumpet great with a statue in New Orleans |
| 35% | CARS | 4 | Things not allowed in New York's Central Park |
| 35% | SELIG | 5 | Former MLB commissioner honored with a statue in Milwaukee |
| 34% | SARATOGA | 8 | ___ Springs (city in New York with a horse track) |
| 34% | RYE | 3 | New York city with a marina |
| 34% | GATES | 5 | 2005 Christo display in New York City, with "the" |
| 34% | ART | 3 | The "A" in New York City's "MoMA" |
| 33% | SOSA | 4 | Athlete feted with a New York City ticker-tape parade in 1998 |
| 33% | LIBERTY | 7 | Island with famous statue in New York harbor |
| 33% | UTICA | 5 | New York city with a name from antiquity |
| 33% | SARATOGASPRINGS | 15 | New York city with a historic race course |
| 33% | MADABOUTYOU | 11 | Sitcom set in New York City that featured Carol Burnett in a recurring role as Jamie's mother (3 wds.) |
| 33% | PARK | 4 | New York City's Central ___ |
| 32% | ILLEGAL | 7 | Like owning a ferret in New York City |
| 32% | GRAND | 5 | New York City's ___ Central Station |
| 32% | RIVERSIDE | 9 | New York City's — Park |
| 32% | DIAMONDJIMBRADY | 15 | Tycoon who was the first person in New York City to own a car |
| 32% | TABOO | 5 | Like eating pizza with a fork and knife in New York City |
| 32% | HAAGENDAZS | 10 | New York City-born ice cream brand with a Danish-sounding name |