| 100% | SCHELL | 6 | 1961 Best Actor for "Judgment at Nuremberg" |
| 49% | DAILEY | 6 | Dan ___, 1948 Best Actor nominee for "When My Baby Smiles at Me" |
| 48% | GARLAND | 7 | Judy —, Best Actress in a Supporting Role Oscar nominee for Judgment at Nuremberg |
| 46% | SCHELL | 6 | 1961 Best Actor Maximilian |
| 46% | OLIVIER | 7 | Best Actor for "Hamlet," 1948 |
| 43% | SCHELL | 6 | Best Actor of 1961 |
| 43% | CLINTEASTWOOD | 13 | Actor and filmmaker who won an Oscar for Best Director at 74 for "Million Dollar Baby": 2 wds. |
| 43% | CAPOTE | 6 | Hoffman won Best Actor for playing him |
| 42% | FOXX | 4 | Best Actor winner for "Ray" |
| 42% | GARYCOOPER | 10 | 1952 Best Actor for 37- and 38-Across |
| 42% | KEHUYQUAN | 9 | 2023 Best Supporting Actor Oscar winner for his role in "Everything Everywhere All at Once": 3 wds. |
| 42% | NOLTE | 5 | Best Actor nominee for "Affliction," 1998 |
| 42% | OTOOLE | 6 | Best Actor nominee for "Venus," 2006 |
| 42% | HANNIBALLECTER | 14 | Best Actor role for Anthony Hopkins |
| 42% | MALEK | 5 | Best Actor winner for "Bohemian Rhapsody" |
| 42% | WALTERPIDGEON | 13 | Best Actor nominee for “Mrs. Miniver” |
| 42% | IRONS | 5 | Best Actor Oscar winner for 1990 |
| 41% | CASTINGDOUBT | 12 | "Is he really the best actor for the role?" |
| 41% | EDWARDNORTON | 12 | Best Actor nominee for "American History X" |
| 41% | STEPHENREA | 10 | Best Actor nominee for "The Crying Game" |
| 41% | LIAMNEESON | 10 | Best Actor nominee for “Schindler’s List” |
| 41% | SPALL | 5 | Timothy —, 2014 Cannes Film Festival Best Actor for Mr Turner |
| 40% | HOLBROOK | 8 | Best Actor Tony winner for "Mark Twain Tonight!" |
| 40% | COLINFIRTH | 10 | Best Actor winner for "The King's Speech" |
| 40% | DENIRO | 6 | Best Actor Oscar winner for playing Jake LaMotta |
| 40% | ADAMDRIVER | 10 | Best Actor nominee for 2019's "Marriage Story" |
| 40% | DAVIDNIVEN | 10 | Best Actor Oscar winner for ''SEParate Tables'' (1958) |
| 40% | CHIWETELEJIOFOR | 15 | Best Actor nominee for "12 Years a Slave" |
| 40% | FOXX | 4 | 2004 Best Actor winner for "Ray" |
| 40% | DERN | 4 | 2013 Best Actor nominee for "Nebraska" |