| 100% | ALOU | 4 | 1968-69 Pirates All-Star |
| 51% | CHUCK | 5 | ___ Taylor All Stars |
| 50% | BARNETT | 7 | 1968 N.B.A. All-Star Dick |
| 48% | RACE | 4 | "RuPaul's Drag ___ All Stars" |
| 48% | CHUCK | 5 | ___ Taylor All Stars (Converse sneakers) |
| 48% | CLOSEST | 7 | Proxima Centauri, of all stars |
| 47% | BENITO | 6 | Five-time All Star catcher Santiago |
| 47% | KOBE | 4 | 4-time all star mvp bryant |
| 47% | SNEAKER | 7 | Chuck Taylor All Star, e.g. |
| 47% | ISAAC | 5 | "Project Runway All Stars" judge Mizrahi |
| 47% | HIGHTOPS | 8 | Some classic Chuck Taylor All Stars |
| 46% | SMASH | 5 | The band that sang All Star; __ Mouth |
| 46% | MILANO | 6 | Alyssa who hosts "Project Runway All Stars" |
| 45% | MTV | 3 | Cable channel that airs "The Challenge: All Stars" |
| 44% | ALDA | 4 | "Paper Lion" star, 1968 |
| 44% | WONDERWOMAN | 11 | Character who debuted in All Star Comics, December 1941 |
| 44% | ISIAHTHOMAS | 11 | *12-time 35-Down All Star and TV analyst |
| 44% | ROBERTOCLEMENTE | 15 | Pirates star of the 1960s: 2 wds. |
| 44% | NEAREST | 7 | Like Proxima Centauri, of all stars but the sun |
| 44% | ISAACMIZRAHI | 12 | Fashion designer and judge on "Project Runway All Stars" |
| 43% | PLANETOFTHEAPES | 15 | 1968 movie starring 17- and 18-Across |
| 43% | OLIVER | 6 | 1968 film starring Ron Moody as Fagin |
| 43% | HAHN | 4 | "Agatha All Along" star Kathryn |
| 42% | LANACONDOR | 10 | Star of the "To All the Boys" series |
| 42% | STAR | 4 | 1968 biopic starring Julie Andrews as Gertrude Lawrence |
| 42% | HES | 3 | ___ All That (2021 movie starring Addison Rae) |
| 42% | RAE | 3 | He's All That star Addison |
| 42% | LANA | 4 | "To All the Boys" star Condor |
| 42% | OTOOLE | 6 | "The Lion in Winter" star, 1968 |
| 42% | YOURETHETOP | 11 | Song mentioning all the starred answers |