| 100% | MACKANDMABEL | 12 | 1975 Tony-nominated musical, including a 1966 Tony-nominated musical |
| 61% | KISSMEKATE | 10 | 1949 Tony-winning musical, including a 1954 Tony-winning musical |
| 52% | ANYTHINGGOES | 12 | 2011 Tony-winning musical revival, including a 1982 Tony-winning musical |
| 47% | NEWSIES | 7 | Tony-nominated musical based on a 1992 Disney movie |
| 44% | ALADDIN | 7 | Animated film made into a Tony-nominated Broadway musical |
| 43% | EQUUS | 5 | 1975 Tony-winning play about a stableboy |
| 43% | WAITRESS | 8 | Broadway musical written by 31-Across that was nominated for four Tony Awards and a Grammy Award |
| 43% | EQUUS | 5 | 1975 Tony-winning play with a Latin name |
| 43% | SWEETCHARITY | 12 | 1966 musical about a taxi dancer |
| 42% | GWENVERDON | 10 | Actress and dancer who won four Tony Awards, including Best Leading Actress in a Musical for "Damn Yankees" (2 wds.) |
| 42% | MARYMARTIN | 10 | Actress and singer who won four Tony Awards, including Best Leading Actress in a Musical for "Peter Pan" (2 wds.) |
| 42% | MAGEE | 5 | Patrick who won a 1966 Tony for "Marat/Sade" |
| 41% | LUV | 3 | Comedy nominated for a 1965 Tony |
| 40% | THEACT | 6 | Musical for which Liza Minnelli won a 1978 Tony |
| 40% | WIZ | 3 | 1975 musical with a Yellow Brick Road, with "The" |
| 40% | IDOIDO | 6 | Repetitively titled 1966 musical about a marriage |
| 40% | PARADE | 6 | Tony award-winning musical revival; a procession |
| 40% | IDOIDO | 6 | 1966 musical including the song "When the Kids Get Married" |
| 39% | IDO | 3 | When repeated, a 1966 musical based on "The Fourposter" |
| 39% | WIZ | 3 | 1975 Best Musical Tony winner, with "The" |
| 38% | ELLIOT | 6 | "Billy ___" (British dance film that inspired a Tony-winning musical) |
| 38% | FEY | 3 | Comedian Tina who was nominated for a 2018 Tony Award |
| 38% | NEWSIES | 7 | Tony-winning musical based on a 1992 Christian Bale film |
| 38% | PIPPIN | 6 | Musical for which Ben Vereen won a Tony |
| 38% | CABARET | 7 | 1966 musical based on "I Am a Camera" |
| 37% | LEVI | 4 | "Chuck" actor Zachary who was nominated for a 2016 Tony Award |
| 37% | JELLYSLASTJAM | 13 | Tony-nominated musical of 1992 |
| 37% | DEAREVANHANSEN | 14 | 2017 Tony-winning musical about a teenager with a social anxiety disorder: 3 wds. |
| 37% | HADES | 5 | Antagonist (and namesake) of a 2019 Tony-winning musical set partly in the underworld |
| 37% | SPAMALOT | 8 | Tony-winning musical that includes the song "He Is Not Dead Yet" |