| 100% | MMMBOP | 6 | 1997 #1 hit with a nonsense title |
| 81% | MMMBOP | 6 | 1997 #1 hit with a nonsense chorus |
| 59% | RAMADING | 8 | *1957 hit by the Edsels with a nonsense title |
| 56% | LOLA | 4 | Kinks hit with a spelled-out title |
| 56% | LOLA | 4 | 1970 hit with a spelled-out title |
| 56% | TROUBLE | 7 | Elvis hit with a spelled-out title |
| 56% | MMMBOP | 6 | 1997 pop hit with a nonsensical refrain |
| 55% | TAKEONME | 8 | 1985 Billboard No. 1 hit with a heavily rotoscoped music video |
| 54% | ESOBESO | 7 | 1962 pop hit with a foreign title |
| 54% | ESOBESO | 7 | Paul Anka hit with a rhyming title |
| 54% | MELLOWYELLOW | 12 | 1966 Donovan hit with a rhyming title |
| 54% | ESOBESO | 7 | 1962 pop hit with a rhyming title |
| 54% | THNKSFRTHMMRS | 13 | 2007 rock hit with a disemvoweled title |
| 54% | STUPIDCUPID | 11 | Connie Francis hit with a rhyming title |
| 54% | HALO | 4 | Beyoncé hit with a "heavenly" title |
| 54% | YMCA | 4 | Village People hit with a spelled-out title |
| 53% | ERESTU | 6 | 1974 hit with a Spanish title |
| 53% | THREETIMESALADY | 15 | Commodores hit with a multiplicative title |
| 53% | ESOBESO | 7 | Anka hit with a Spanish title |
| 53% | BADANDBOUJEE | 12 | 2016 No. 1 hit with a refrain that begins "Rain drop, drop top" |
| 53% | ARRIVEDERCIROMA | 15 | 1950's song hit with a foreign-language title |
| 53% | ROCKLOBSTER | 11 | B-52s hit with a crustacean in the title |
| 52% | BLACKBEATLES | 12 | 2016 Rae Sremmurd hit with a "B.B." title: 2 wds. |
| 51% | ERESTU | 6 | 1974 hit with a Spanish title meaning "You are" |
| 51% | THONGSONG | 9 | 2000 Sisqó hit with a rhyming title |
| 51% | OTIS | 4 | Redding with a posthumous No. 1 hit |
| 50% | BEYONCE | 7 | Famous singer with a hit album titled Lemonade |
| 50% | GLAD | 4 | "___ You Came," The Wanted hit with a "happy" title |
| 50% | ABBA | 4 | Alphabetically first pop group with a No. 1 hit |
| 50% | QUARTERTO | 9 | With 16-Across, title time in a 1961 #1 hit by Gary U.S. Bonds |