| 100% | SUPERBAD | 8 | 2007 hit comedy with a character who dubbed himself McLovin |
| 41% | SUPERBAD | 8 | 2007 movie with a character named McLovin |
| 33% | CALVIN | 6 | Character who appears with Hobbes in a comic strip |
| 33% | ROMEO | 5 | Character who said "Thus with a kiss I die" |
| 32% | KATE | 4 | Shakespearean character who "had a tongue with a tang" |
| 32% | FAUST | 5 | Goethe character who makes a pact with the devil |
| 32% | PAM | 3 | "The Office" character who had a romance with Jim |
| 32% | LUCY | 4 | "Peanuts" character who pranks Charlie Brown with a football |
| 32% | FAUST | 5 | Classic literary character who makes a deal with the devil |
| 32% | TOBIAS | 6 | “Arrested Development” character who struggles with being a “never-nude” |
| 31% | DOROTHY | 7 | Character who sings with the Scarecrow in "If I Only Had a Brain" |
| 31% | MAUI | 4 | "Moana 2" character who shares a name with a Hawaiian island |
| 31% | OSLO | 4 | "Money Heist" character who shares a name with Norway's capital |
| 31% | DORA | 4 | ___ the Explorer, Nickelodeon character who is celebrated with a National Day |
| 31% | BESS | 4 | Opera title character who's initially in a relationship with Crown |
| 31% | IMBRUGLIA | 9 | Natalie who had a hit with Torn |
| 31% | IRENE | 5 | Cara who had a hit with "Fame" |
| 31% | RENO | 4 | Final Fantasy character who shares his name with a U.S. city |
| 31% | SILK | 4 | Spider-Man character who shares her name with a spider’s product |
| 31% | ROD | 3 | Stewart who had a hit with "Forever Young" |
| 31% | IAN | 3 | Janis who had a hit with "At Seventeen" |
| 30% | ARLO | 4 | Guthrie with a folk hit that was adapted into a 1969 comedy film |
| 30% | TONTO | 5 | TV character who said "Him a beauty. Like mountain with snow - silver-white" |
| 30% | YODA | 4 | Sci-fi character who speaks with a distinctive object-subject-verb word order |
| 30% | JOLSON | 6 | Who had a #1 hit with "Toot Toot Tootsie (Goo'bye)" |
| 30% | SCTV | 4 | Canadian comedy show with a character named Edith Prickley |
| 30% | TWENTYONE | 9 | __ Pilots; duo who had a 2016 hit with Heathens |
| 30% | LEGEND | 6 | John who had a hit with All Of Me |
| 30% | ZENDAYA | 7 | Singer who had a hit with Rewrite the Stars |
| 30% | TOMJONES | 8 | Welsh singer who had a massive hit with Delilah |