| 100% | KRIS | 4 | 2009 "American Idol" winner ___ Allen |
| 85% | KRIS | 4 | ___ Allen, 2009 "American Idol" winner |
| 75% | KRIS | 4 | "American Idol" winner ___ Allen |
| 75% | KRIS | 4 | "American Idol" winner Allen |
| 69% | KRIS | 4 | "American Idol" eighth-season winner ___ Allen |
| 66% | CLARKSON | 8 | First American Idol winner, Kelly __ |
| 66% | UNDERWOOD | 9 | Carrie __, 2005 American Idol winner |
| 65% | CARRIEUNDERWOOD | 15 | Country singer and American Idol winner |
| 57% | KRIS | 4 | "Idol" winner Allen |
| 56% | CLARKSON | 8 | Winner of American Idol Season One |
| 54% | RUBEN | 5 | "American Idol" winner ___ Studdard |
| 54% | RUBEN | 5 | ''American Idol'' winner Studdard |
| 54% | LEE | 3 | "American Idol" winner DeWyze |
| 54% | RUBEN | 5 | "American Idol" winner Studdard |
| 54% | KELLY | 5 | "American Idol" winner Clarkson |
| 53% | ADAM | 4 | 2009 "American Idol" runner-up Lambert |
| 53% | JORDINSPARKS | 12 | Youngest "American Idol" winner |
| 52% | KELLY | 5 | First "American Idol" winner Clarkson |
| 52% | RUBEN | 5 | 2003 "American Idol" winner Studdard |
| 52% | HICKS | 5 | 2006 "American Idol" winner Taylor __ |
| 48% | CLARKSON | 8 | The first winner of American Idol, Kelly __ |
| 47% | CLARKSON | 8 | Kelly, first winner of American Idol |
| 47% | KARA | 4 | 2009-10 “American Idol” judge DioGuardi |
| 46% | KELLY | 5 | ___ Clarkson, former "American Idol" winner who hosts an eponymous talk show |
| 45% | PAULA | 5 | ___ Abdul, Judge on "American Idol" from 2002 to 2009 |
| 45% | KELLYCLARKSON | 13 | "American Idol" winner whose newest album is titled "Meaning of Life": 2 wds. |
| 45% | KELLYCLARKSON | 13 | "American Idol" winner who voices Delta Dawn in "Trolls World Tour" (2 wds.) |
| 45% | HICKS | 5 | 2006 American Idol |
| 43% | KELLYCLARKSON | 13 | "American Idol" winner who was a coach on "The Voice" for nine seasons (2 wds.) |
| 43% | KELLYCLARKSON | 13 | "American Idol" winner who has hosted a daytime television talk show since 2019 (2 wds.) |