| 100% | ARROW | 5 | 2012-2020 CW show about a bow-wielding superhero |
| 50% | ARROW | 5 | The CW show about a vigilante archer |
| 45% | DAREDEVIL | 9 | Netflix show about a blind Marvel superhero |
| 41% | SMASH | 5 | 2012 TV series about a Broadway show |
| 40% | BATWOMAN | 8 | Show on the CW about Kate Kane, a Gotham City superhero |
| 39% | ARROW | 5 | TV show featuring a bow-wielding vigilante |
| 39% | SMASH | 5 | 2012-2013 TV show about the creation of a Broadway musical |
| 38% | CHEERS | 6 | Show about a school pep squad? |
| 38% | JANETHEVIRGIN | 13 | The CW show based on a Venezuelan telenovela about a girl who is accidentally artificially inseminated (3 wds.) |
| 38% | ALLRISE | 7 | CBS show about a judge |
| 38% | MRROBOT | 7 | USA show about a hacker |
| 37% | FAMILYTIES | 10 | Show about a mom-and-pop neckwear business? |
| 37% | ANNIEGETYOURGUM | 15 | Broadway show about a "chewsy" cowgirl? |
| 37% | GLEE | 4 | TV show about a school choir |
| 37% | COUGARTOWN | 10 | Show about a village and its mountain lion problem? |
| 36% | GLEE | 4 | TV show about a high school choir |
| 36% | DOCTORWHO | 9 | Long-running show about a Time Lord |
| 36% | GOSSIP | 6 | __ Girl, TV show about a mysterious blogger |
| 36% | OOISENOUGH | 10 | '70s-'80s show about a big family |
| 36% | GLEE | 4 | TV show about a high-school choir |
| 36% | CAGE | 4 | "Luke ___" (Netflix show about a Marvel hero) |
| 36% | SQUIDGAME | 9 | Hit Korean show about a killer competition |
| 36% | DOUG | 4 | 1990s Nickelodeon show about a preteen boy |
| 36% | PODPROGRAM | 10 | TV show about a group of whales? |
| 36% | ROC | 3 | '90s TV show about a garbage collector |
| 36% | TEDLASSO | 8 | Show about a US football coach on a soccer team |
| 36% | NIKITA | 6 | TV show about a rebel spy and assassin |
| 36% | BEWITCHED | 9 | 60s TV show about a modern housewife witch |
| 36% | QUEENSUGAR | 10 | Oprah Winfrey Network show about a family farm |
| 36% | AVENUE | 6 | 666 Park __, TV show about a haunted building |