| 100% | KEANU | 5 | 2016 Key & Peele action-comedy film about a missing cat |
| 48% | KEANU | 5 | 2016 Key and Peele action comedy |
| 44% | NEMO | 4 | "Finding __": Pixar film about a missing fish |
| 43% | TED | 3 | Mark Wahlberg comedy film about a talking toy bear |
| 42% | KEANU | 5 | Title kitten in a Key and Peele action comedy |
| 42% | MRMOM | 5 | 1983 Comedy film about a stay-at-home dad: 2 wds. |
| 41% | TOY | 3 | 1995 animated buddy adventure comedy film, "___ Story" which is about a cowboy doll named Woody and an astronaut action figure Buzz Lightyear |
| 41% | KEANU | 5 | Cat in the title of a 2016 movie starring Key & Peele |
| 40% | HATARI | 6 | John Wayne romantic comedy film about a group of professional game catchers in Africa |
| 40% | LOVING | 6 | 2016 film about a 1967 Supreme Court case |
| 39% | LEBOWSKI | 8 | "The Big ___," 1998 crime comedy film about a bowler starring Julianne Moore and Jeff Bridges |
| 39% | MURDER | 6 | Dial M for __, Hitchcock film about missing keys |
| 38% | BATHMANANDROBIN | 15 | 1997 action film about a spa duo? |
| 38% | HOMEWARDBOUND | 13 | 1993 film about a bulldog and a golden retriever (and a cat) (2 wds.) |
| 37% | KEANU | 5 | 2016 comedy movie starring Key & Peele |
| 36% | LIFE | 4 | "Bad Boys For ___," American action comedy film starring Will Smith that had a digital release in 2020 |
| 35% | GONEBABYGONE | 12 | 1998 18-Across novel about a missing woman that was made into a 2007 Ben Affleck film: 3 wds. |
| 35% | RUNDOWN | 7 | "The ___," action comedy film starring Dwayne Johnson as a bounty hunter, that released internationally as "Welcome to the Jungle" |
| 35% | SOOT | 4 | Film about a furnace |
| 35% | PATINA | 6 | Film about a statue? |
| 35% | GHOSTBUSTERS | 12 | 2016 Melissa McCarthy film about a parapsychological business starring a female ensemble cast |
| 35% | FREAKYFRIDAY | 12 | Fantasy-comedy film about a mother and daughter who swap bodies (2 wds.) |
| 34% | DOLITTLE | 8 | Upcoming fantasy comedy film starring Robert Downey Jr. about a vet who can speak to animals |
| 34% | BIOPIC | 6 | Film about a real person |
| 34% | APOCALYPSESNOW | 14 | Film about a devastating blizzard? |
| 34% | BEASTOFEDEN | 11 | Film about a biblical serpent? |
| 34% | THEHOUNDOFMUSIC | 15 | Film about a composing pooch? |
| 34% | JURASSICLARK | 12 | Film about a prehistoric songbird? |
| 34% | BEVERLYHILLSCOW | 15 | Film about a Jersey girl? |
| 34% | HAS | 3 | "London ___ Fallen," a 2016 action film starring Gerard Butler and Aaron Eckhart |