| 100% | WIZARD | 6 | A man who performs magic like Harry Potter |
| 55% | SORCERESS | 9 | A woman who performs magic, like a witch |
| 42% | LIVED | 5 | Harry Potter a.k.a. The Boy Who ___ |
| 41% | SCAR | 4 | Harry Potter has one shaped like a lightning bolt |
| 41% | SCAR | 4 | Harry Potter's is shaped like a lightning bolt |
| 40% | SCAR | 4 | Harry Potter's mark that's shaped like a lightning bolt |
| 39% | VAIN | 4 | Like a man who thinks he's God's gift to women |
| 39% | TIN | 3 | Like the man in Oz who wanted a heart |
| 36% | MAGGIESMITH | 11 | Actress in the Harry Potter movies who was royally dubbed a dame in 1990: 2 wds. |
| 36% | MAGICAL | 7 | Like Harry Potter's world |
| 36% | RON | 3 | ___ Weasley, character from "Harry Potter" who had a memorable friendship with Harry and Hermione |
| 35% | IRISHMAN | 8 | A man who is from Ireland |
| 35% | ALISONBRIE | 10 | "Mad Men" actress who formerly performed as a clown named Sunny: 2 wds. |
| 35% | HAGRID | 6 | Character who tells Harry Potter he's a wizard |
| 35% | TUCKER | 6 | Cameron ___, music teacher from the TV series "Modern Family" who performs like a Broadway star in unusual places |
| 35% | KNIGHT | 6 | A man who competed in jousting matches |
| 35% | WIDOWER | 7 | A man who has lost his wife |
| 35% | ALI | 3 | Muhammad ___, a man who could float like a butterfly and sting like a bee |
| 35% | IMET | 4 | "___ a man who wasn't there" |
| 34% | DEATHLY | 7 | Like the Hallows in a Harry Potter title |
| 34% | GLADIATOR | 9 | A man who fought animals in the Colosseum |
| 34% | SHANIA | 6 | Twain, who sings Man! I Feel Like a Woman! |
| 34% | BACHELOR | 8 | A man who is not married; an academic degree |
| 34% | WAND | 4 | Harry Potter's magic stick |
| 33% | SURGEON | 7 | A doctor who performs operations |
| 33% | BLUEINTHEFACE | 13 | Exasperated...or like a man who's a member of a certain performance Group? |
| 33% | JENIFERLEWIS | 12 | "Think Like a Man" actress who plays a grandma on "Black-ish": 2 wds. |
| 33% | KING | 4 | Man who wears a crown |
| 33% | NOONE | 5 | Who "knows what it's like to be the bad man," according to a 1971 hit by the Who |
| 33% | SNOG | 4 | Show affection, like Harry Potter and Ginny Weasley |