| 100% | ERNE | 4 | A white-tailed predatory seabird that eats fish |
| 45% | STINGRAYS | 9 | Fishes with long tails that migrate a long distance |
| 44% | MERMAID | 7 | Woman with a fish tail that lives in water |
| 43% | BONINESS | 8 | Supervisor + 9 = Quality that makes a fish hard to eat |
| 43% | SEAHORSE | 8 | Fish with a curly tail that swims upright |
| 42% | OPAH | 4 | A large deep-water fish that is often prey for Great white sharks |
| 42% | OUROBOROS | 9 | Ancient symbol of infinity that depicts a snake eating its own tail |
| 40% | OTTER | 5 | River mammal that eats fish |
| 40% | ERN | 3 | Bird with a white tail |
| 40% | OTTER | 5 | Semi-aquatic weasel-like mammal that eats fish |
| 40% | BAMBI | 5 | Disney character with a white tail |
| 39% | MERGANSER | 9 | Duck that eats fish; anagram of near germs |
| 37% | BARRACUDA | 9 | A Heart song named after a predatory fish |
| 37% | ROD | 3 | A long pole that fishermen use to fish |
| 36% | GRUB | 4 | Witchetty ___, white, wood-eating larvae that are a delicacy in Australia |
| 36% | EEL | 3 | Fish that resembles a snake |
| 36% | EEL | 3 | Fish that resembles a serpent |
| 36% | CARP | 4 | Fish that complains a lot? |
| 36% | TERMITE | 7 | Insect that eats wood, can destroy a house |
| 36% | PET | 3 | Family member that eats from a food bowl |
| 35% | PIKE | 4 | Predatory fish with a long nose |
| 35% | SEAHORSE | 8 | Fish that can twine its tail |
| 35% | SCAD | 4 | Fish with a deeply forked tail |
| 35% | EEL | 3 | Fish that looks like a snake |
| 35% | LOX | 3 | Fish that is a bagel topper |
| 35% | TUNA | 4 | Fish that's a sushi staple |
| 35% | LOX | 3 | Fish that might accompany a schmear |
| 35% | EEL | 3 | Fish that begins as a leptocephalus |
| 35% | EEL | 3 | Fish that comes with a "charge" |
| 35% | EEL | 3 | Fish that can give a shock |