| 100% | HAT | 3 | Accessory worn by Mr. Peanut |
| 95% | HAT | 3 | Clothing accessory worn by Mr. Peanut |
| 73% | MONOCLE | 7 | Corrective lens worn by Mr. Peanut |
| 72% | MONOCLE | 7 | Single corrective lens worn by Mr. Peanut |
| 58% | SASH | 4 | Accessory worn by Miss America |
| 58% | TIE | 3 | Accessory worn by Yogi Bear |
| 58% | ARMBANDS | 8 | Accessories worn by soccer captains |
| 57% | BIB | 3 | Accessory worn by a dental patient |
| 56% | TIE | 3 | Accessory worn by Annie in "Annie Hall" |
| 56% | ASCOT | 5 | Accessory worn by Fred in "Scooby-Doo" |
| 56% | HAT | 3 | Accessory worn by both Mario and Luigi |
| 56% | EYEPATCH | 8 | Facial accessory worn by pirates |
| 56% | CAP | 3 | Head accessory worn by golfers |
| 56% | VEILS | 5 | Lacy accessories worn by brides |
| 55% | ASCOT | 5 | Accessory worn by Fred in "Scooby-Doo" cartoons |
| 55% | BLACKBELT | 9 | Accessory worn by a karate expert: 2 wds. |
| 55% | BOA | 3 | Feathered accessory worn by some dancers |
| 55% | SASH | 4 | Fashion accessory worn by pageant contestants |
| 55% | DEERSTALKERCAP | 14 | Iconic accessory worn by 1-Down |
| 55% | TOPHAT | 6 | Monopoly token worn by Mr. Monopoly |
| 55% | CAPS | 4 | Head accessories worn by baseball players |
| 54% | BOWTIE | 6 | A neck accessory worn by Donald Duck |
| 54% | GLASSES | 7 | Face accessory worn by Aniston and Blanchett |
| 54% | SPUROFTHEMOUNT | 14 | Cowboy-boot accessory worn by a horse? |
| 54% | HEADSETS | 8 | Telephone accessories worn by call center employees |
| 54% | CANE | 4 | Mr. Peanut accessory |
| 54% | HAT | 3 | Mr. Peanut accessory |
| 54% | MONOCLE | 7 | Mr. Peanut accessory |
| 53% | MONOCLE | 7 | Mr. Peanut wears one |
| 52% | BUFF | 4 | Tribe-identifying cloth accessory worn by a "Survivor" contestant |