| 100% | LALLANA | 7 | Adam —, England, Liverpool and former Southampton midfield footballer |
| 46% | LALLANA | 7 | Adam —, England and Brighton and Hove Albion footballer |
| 46% | CAN | 3 | Emre —, Liverpool and Germany midfield footballer |
| 45% | ROCASTLE | 8 | David —, former Arsenal and Leeds United midfield footballer; 1988 England debutant |
| 44% | EMYRHUWS | 8 | Wales, Ipswich Town and former Cardiff City midfield footballer |
| 43% | IKECHIANYA | 10 | Scotland and former Derby County midfield footballer born in 1988 |
| 42% | PLATT | 5 | David —, former England and Aston Villa midfield footballer; 1990 PFA Players' Player of the Year award winner |
| 40% | NGOLO | 5 | Former France and Chelsea midfielder; 2016-17 FWA Footballer of the Year |
| 40% | PLATT | 5 | David —, former England and Arsenal midfield footballer; 1990 PFA Players' Player of the Year award winner |
| 39% | ELABD | 5 | Adam —, former Brighton and Hove Albion and Egypt footballer; brother of rugby coach Joe |
| 38% | KEOWN | 5 | Martin —, former England, Everton and Arsenal footballer who retired in 2005 |
| 38% | DELPH | 5 | Fabian —, England and Manchester City midfield footballer |
| 38% | STJOHN | 6 | Ian —, former Scotland and Liverpool footballer; co-star of ITV programme Saint and Greavsie |
| 37% | DELPH | 5 | Fabian —, former Man City and Everton midfielder; in England's 2018 World Cup Finals squad |
| 37% | ALANHANSEN | 10 | Former Liverpool and Scotland footballer whose credits as a pundit include BBC TV's Match of the Day |
| 37% | WADDLE | 6 | Chris —, former Tottenham Hotspur, Newcastle United, Sheffield Wednesday and England footballer; Burnley manager from 1997-98 |
| 37% | ELANO | 5 | Former Brazil and Santos midfield footballer at Manchester City from 2007-09 |
| 35% | SAMIR | 5 | & 19D Former France and Manchester City midfield footballer; 2014 League Cup Final winner |
| 34% | DECO | 4 | Former Portugal midfield footballer; Barcelona 2006 Champions League Final winner |
| 33% | EDEN | 4 | Former home of Adam and Eve |
| 33% | LUIZ | 4 | — Diaz, Colombia and Liverpool footballer |
| 32% | DELPH | 5 | Fabian —, England and Everton midfielder/defender |
| 31% | STERLING | 8 | Raheem —, England and Manchester City FC midfielder |
| 31% | ASHE | 4 | Adam —, former Glasgow Warriors and Scotland rugby union back-rower |
| 31% | DELPH | 5 | Fabian —, England and Manchester City FC midfielder/defender |
| 31% | HENDRIE | 7 | Lee —, Aston Villa midfield footballer; 1998 England cap winner against the Czech Republic |
| 30% | NEYMAR | 6 | Santos and former Barcelona footballer who is Brazil's all-time top goalscorer |
| 30% | IKECHIANYA | 10 | Scotland and Derby County midfield footballer born in 1988 |
| 30% | DELPH | 5 | Fabian —, England and Manchester City FC midfielder and defender |