| 100% | SPICES | 6 | Add these to mulled wine |
| 62% | CINNAMON | 8 | Spice added to mulled wine or buns |
| 52% | LIMEJUICE | 9 | Add this to tequila, triple sec to make margaritas |
| 52% | COUNTRY | 7 | Add this to Western to make a music genre |
| 49% | INJURY | 6 | Add insult to this |
| 48% | HIGHLIGHT | 9 | Add this shiny makeup to the tops of cheekbones |
| 47% | CRUSHED | 7 | Did this to grapes to turn them into wine |
| 46% | TABLESPOON | 10 | Add 15 to this for a cup |
| 46% | AGE | 3 | Every birthday adds to this |
| 46% | BUTTER | 6 | Herbed or plain, add this smooth dairy to a scone |
| 46% | SIFT | 4 | Do this to flour before adding it to a recipe |
| 46% | PLANTS | 6 | Add some greenery to your desk with these |
| 45% | USB | 3 | Add a mouse to a laptop using this connector |
| 44% | FLAMBE | 6 | Add alcohol to a hot pan to create this effect |
| 44% | CORDIAL | 7 | Add water to this syrup to make a drink, squash |
| 44% | INSULT | 6 | This is added to injury to make a situation worse |
| 44% | ACID | 4 | What wine or citrus adds to a sauce |
| 43% | TICS | 4 | Idiosyncrasies added to this puzzle's longest answers |
| 43% | DATE | 4 | (3/6) Add this detail to indicate the day you wrote the letter |
| 43% | TANNIN | 6 | This can give a bitter taste to tea and red wine |
| 42% | MULL | 4 | Heat and add spices to, as wine |
| 41% | SUM | 3 | It all adds up to this |
| 41% | BEET | 4 | McDonald's Aussie "McOz" Burger uniquely has this added to it |
| 41% | CELERY | 6 | A stalk of this is usually added to a Bloody Mary |
| 40% | USETHEON/OFFSWITCH | 18 | Add light, or not (and do this 13 more times to solve this puzzle) |
| 40% | ABLE | 4 | Add a B to 48-Across, and you'll be ___ to get this word! |
| 40% | TEA | 3 | You can add milk to this hot beverage |
| 40% | RECOMMENDS | 10 | A good waiter usually does this to help a diner pair the right wine with the entree |
| 39% | OENOLOGY | 8 | Mulled wine? |
| 39% | CRONE | 5 | Witch, and the combination of letters added to this puzzle's theme answers |