| 100% | ODDEST | 6 | Adjective for a "Ripley's Believe It or Not!" feature |
| 63% | ODD | 3 | Like a "Ripley's Believe It or Not!" item |
| 59% | ODD | 3 | Suitable for "Ripley's Believe It or Not!" |
| 57% | ODDITY | 6 | Item fit for "Ripley's Believe It or Not!" |
| 55% | WEIRDFACTS | 10 | Fodder for Ripley’s “Believe It or Not!” |
| 54% | ABNORMAL | 8 | Like things in "Ripley's Believe It or Not!" |
| 53% | WEIRD | 5 | Like most things in "Ripley's Believe It or Not!" |
| 53% | ODD | 3 | Like most things in "Ripley's Believe It or Not!" |
| 53% | WEIRD | 5 | Unusual, like most things in "Ripley's Believe It or Not!" |
| 52% | NEHI | 4 | Brand that sponsored the "Ripley's Believe It or Not!" radio show |
| 45% | RIPLEY | 6 | Believe It or Not! museum surname |
| 45% | NOT | 3 | "Ripley's Believe It or ___!" |
| 45% | NOT | 3 | "Ripley's Believe It or ___" |
| 44% | EEE | 3 | Believe it or not, this shoe width is three below the widest width that's regularly made |
| 42% | WIN | 3 | It's not a loss or a tie |
| 42% | LOSS | 4 | It's not a win or a tie |
| 41% | NYC | 3 | Where Billy the Kid was born, believe it or not: Abbr. |
| 41% | FACT | 4 | Something known to be true, whether you believe it or not |
| 41% | SPORK | 5 | It's a portmanteau, but not for "salt pork" |
| 41% | SKORT | 5 | It's a portmanteau, but not for "ski resort" |
| 41% | SMOG | 4 | It's a portmanteau, but not for "small dog" |
| 41% | MATH | 4 | Subject of debate as to whether or not it’s a science |
| 41% | DRIVINGAGE | 10 | For a full license, it's 17 or 18 in most states |
| 40% | ONEOVERPAR | 10 | It's not bad for a duffer |
| 40% | TACO | 4 | Food subject to internet debate over whether or not it's a sandwich |
| 40% | SKINNY | 6 | Adjective for a lower-calorie version of a margarita or latte |
| 40% | GOUDA | 5 | Dutch city or a cheese it's famous for |
| 40% | SQUAREPEG | 9 | It's not meant for a 3-Down |
| 40% | LARGEST | 7 | Adjective for Jupiter or a blue whale |
| 40% | LAW | 3 | Pennsylvania has one against catching fish with your bare hands, believe it or not |