| 100% | SLUG | 4 | Animal that's like a shell-less snail |
| 82% | SLUG | 4 | Pest that's like a shell-less snail |
| 58% | ALPACA | 6 | South American animal that's like a small llama |
| 58% | SLUG | 4 | Animal that's similar to a snail |
| 56% | BROCCOLI | 8 | Green vegetable that's like a little tree |
| 55% | AJAR | 4 | Like a door that's open just a little |
| 54% | HARE | 4 | Animal that looks like a rabbit |
| 54% | MOOSE | 5 | Animal that sounds like a dessert |
| 54% | EWE | 3 | Animal that sounds like a pronoun |
| 54% | LLAMA | 5 | Animal that looks like a large alpaca |
| 54% | BOAR | 4 | Animal that sounds like a yawn-inducer |
| 54% | DOE | 3 | Animal that sounds like a musical note |
| 51% | EWE | 3 | Animal that sounds like a tree, a pronoun, and a letter |
| 51% | TAPIR | 5 | Animal that looks like a pig/anteater hybrid (rhymes with "vapor") |
| 51% | STARFISH | 8 | Sea animal that looks like a star |
| 51% | EWE | 3 | Female animal that sounds like a pronoun |
| 51% | EWE | 3 | Female animal that sounds like a vowel |
| 51% | EWE | 3 | Animal that sounds a lot like you? |
| 50% | SLUG | 4 | Snail-like animal that leaves a slime trail |
| 49% | EWE | 3 | Farm animal that sounds like a letter of the alphabet |
| 49% | ACORN | 5 | Nut that looks like it's wearing a little hat |
| 49% | SLY | 3 | Like a wink that suggests "This is our little secret" |
| 49% | MUDPUPPY | 8 | Salamander that sounds like a dirty little dog |
| 48% | TAPIRS | 6 | Large animals that look a little pig-like, are related to rhinos and live in the Amazon |
| 47% | MEW | 3 | Animal cry that sounds like a Greek letter |
| 47% | MOLE | 4 | Animal that's a spy term |
| 46% | AJAR | 4 | Like windows that let a little breeze in, perhaps |
| 46% | EWES | 4 | Beasts that sound a little like "Brooklynese" |
| 46% | TOAD | 4 | Animal that's similar to a frog |
| 46% | RAT | 3 | Animal that's a symbol for snitching |