| 100% | EWE | 3 | Animal that Poseidon turned Theophane into, in myth |
| 52% | REDPANDA | 8 | Animal that Mei turns into in a 2022 Pixar film |
| 52% | RAT | 3 | Animal that Peter Pettigrew turned into, in the Harry Potter books |
| 51% | LLAMA | 5 | Animal that Kuzco is turned into, in "The Emperor's New Groove" |
| 47% | BAT | 3 | Animal that the "What We Do in the Shadows" vampires can turn into |
| 44% | BAT | 3 | Animal that Dracula could turn into |
| 44% | BAT | 3 | Animal that Dracula can turn into |
| 44% | BAT | 3 | Animal that some vampires turn into |
| 44% | BAT | 3 | Animal that a vampire could turn into |
| 44% | STOAT | 5 | Animal that turns white in the winter |
| 43% | AURA | 4 | In myth she was turned into a spring |
| 43% | FROG | 4 | Animal that turned into a prince, after a kiss |
| 39% | LLAMA | 5 | Animal that Prince Kuzco is transformed into in Disney's "The Emperor's New Groove" |
| 39% | DAPHNE | 6 | Nymph turned into a laurel tree, in Greek myth |
| 38% | SMUT | 4 | Disease in crops that turn the cereal into black powder |
| 38% | ABU | 3 | Monkey that Genie temporarily turns into an elephant, in "Aladdin" |
| 38% | MICE | 4 | Animals the witches turn into in Roald Dahl's book |
| 37% | NIKES | 5 | Shoes that turned Lil Bow Wow into Michael Jordan in "Like Mike" |
| 35% | MEAD | 4 | ___ of poetry, beverage in Norse mythology that turns its drinker into an all-knowing scholar |
| 35% | OTTER | 5 | Animal that frolics in streams |
| 35% | PIG | 3 | Animal that wallows in mud |
| 35% | BEAR | 4 | Animal that hibernates in winter |
| 35% | APE | 3 | Animal that swings in forests |
| 35% | PIGS | 4 | Animals that live in pens |
| 35% | MOLES | 5 | Animals that burrow in lawns |
| 34% | PIG | 3 | Animal that lives in a sty |
| 34% | BAT | 3 | Animal that flies in a cave |
| 34% | MULE | 4 | Animal that works in a pack |
| 34% | ASS | 3 | Animal that works in a pack |
| 34% | AMOEBA | 6 | Animal that lives in a cell |