| 100% | RATS | 4 | Animals that the Pied Piper was hired to remove |
| 87% | RATS | 4 | Creatures that the Pied Piper was hired to remove |
| 77% | RAT | 3 | Type of animal the Pied Piper was hired to remove |
| 46% | LAMB | 4 | Animal that the month of March is said to "go out like" |
| 45% | RAT | 3 | Animal that followed the Pied Piper |
| 43% | ASP | 3 | Animal that becomes another animal when w is added to the beginning of its name |
| 42% | HAMELIN | 7 | The Pied Piper was from this town |
| 42% | LAIKA | 5 | Dog that was the first animal to orbit the Earth |
| 41% | HAMELIN | 7 | The Pied Piper was from this place in Germany |
| 41% | FOUND | 5 | ___ to be missing, oxymoron that describes the case of a missing Christmas pie |
| 41% | TAPIRS | 6 | Large animals that look a little pig-like, are related to rhinos and live in the Amazon |
| 39% | RAT | 3 | Rodent that was lured away by the Pied Piper |
| 39% | COBRA | 5 | Animal that the Pokémon Arbok is based on |
| 39% | HAMELIN | 7 | "The Pied Piper of ___," poem written by Robert Browning that is based on a folktale |
| 38% | ELKS | 4 | Animals that are similar to moose |
| 38% | MICE | 4 | Animals that are similar to rats |
| 38% | ELKS | 4 | Animals that are related to moose |
| 38% | ELKS | 4 | Animals that are related to reindeer |
| 38% | HARE | 4 | Animal that lost to the tortoise |
| 38% | FAUNA | 5 | Animals that are native to a region |
| 38% | ELEPHANTS | 9 | Animals that are said to never forget |
| 38% | PETS | 4 | Animals that are part of the family |
| 38% | BATS | 4 | Animals that could be "in the belfry" |
| 38% | DIURNAL | 7 | Animals that are active during the daytime |
| 38% | ELK | 3 | Animal that's related to the reindeer |
| 38% | LLAMA | 5 | Animal that's related to the alpaca |
| 38% | APE | 3 | Animal that is genetically close to humans |
| 38% | SLOTH | 5 | Animal that is the epitome of laziness |
| 37% | POLARBEARS | 10 | Animals that are nearly invisible to infrared detectors |
| 37% | TORTOISE | 8 | Animal that Hermes used to create the lyre |