| 100% | KNOWITALL | 9 | Annoying but useful trivia teammate, maybe |
| 30% | NERD | 4 | Trivia lover, maybe |
| 30% | SLOB | 4 | Annoying roommate, maybe |
| 29% | STOMP | 5 | Annoy downstairs neighbors, maybe |
| 28% | CHAFINGDISH | 11 | Attractive but annoying date? |
| 28% | ORNOT | 5 | "... but maybe I'm wrong" |
| 28% | ORNOT | 5 | ". . . but maybe I'm wrong" |
| 28% | ORNOT | 5 | “. . . but maybe I’m wrong!” |
| 28% | SWALLOW | 7 | Accept, but maybe unhappily |
| 28% | COY | 3 | Shy, but maybe not? |
| 28% | YET | 3 | "Not ___, but maybe later" |
| 26% | SON | 3 | Heir, maybe, but not an heiress |
| 26% | OFFCAMERA | 9 | Heard but not seen, maybe |
| 25% | DATES | 5 | Answers to historical trivia questions, maybe |
| 25% | STOOLIE | 7 | One who sings but maybe shouldn't |
| 25% | PERIL | 5 | Wind or fire, maybe, but not earth |
| 25% | BALLPARK | 8 | A __ figure is close but maybe not precise |
| 24% | IGNORANCE | 9 | Said to be bliss, but highly annoying in others |
| 24% | SENTENCE | 8 | Five to nine, maybe, but not nine to five |
| 23% | ENEMA | 5 | Generally frowned upon, but highly useful, crossword puzzle medical procedure |
| 23% | GISMO | 5 | Useful (but unspecified) device |
| 21% | ORNOT | 5 | "...but maybe that's wrong" |
| 21% | NERDIEST | 8 | Most likely to win at Trivia Night, maybe |
| 20% | HEMP | 4 | Maligned but ultra-useful plant |
| 20% | SNIGLET | 7 | Term for a word that isn't in the dictionary, but maybe should be |
| 19% | DAREIASK | 8 | “Maybe it’s better not knowing, but . . .” |
| 19% | LETON | 5 | Say you don't know but do it with a "wink, wink, nudge, nudge", maybe |
| 19% | ORISITME | 8 | "But maybe I'm alone in thinking this?" |
| 19% | MEAT | 4 | Essence (but maybe not to a vegan) |
| 18% | NITS | 4 | Trivia |