| 100% | SUSPECT | 7 | Any character with a token in Clue |
| 50% | SUSPECT | 7 | Any character in Clue |
| 49% | RAHEEM | 6 | Character with a boombox in "Do the Right Thing" |
| 49% | PROFESSORPLUM | 13 | Clue character with a bow tie |
| 48% | SEBASTIAN | 9 | Character with a Jamaican accent in Disney's "The Little Mermaid" |
| 48% | APU | 3 | "Simpsons" character with a Ph.D. in computer science |
| 47% | DORA | 4 | Animated character with a talking map in her talking backpack |
| 47% | SCARLET | 7 | Character with the red piece in Clue, Miss __ |
| 46% | THEFONZ | 7 | Sitcom character with a leather jacket that's now in the Smithsonian |
| 46% | EEYORE | 6 | Kid-lit character with a long face, in more ways than one |
| 46% | NANCY | 5 | ___ Downs, character with a goth aesthetic played by Fairuza Balk in "The Craft" |
| 45% | LOUNGE | 6 | Room in Clue with a secret passage to the Conservatory |
| 44% | ROO | 3 | Character once stuck in a tree with Tigger |
| 44% | LACHOY | 6 | Food brand since 1922 with a Chinese character in its logo |
| 44% | CALVIN | 6 | Character who appears with Hobbes in a comic strip |
| 44% | ILSA | 4 | Character in a love triangle with Victor and Rick |
| 44% | SON | 3 | Character in a Cat Stevens song with two perspectives |
| 44% | MAGGIESIMPSON | 13 | Cartoon character with a blue hair bow whose long-running series debuted in 1989 (2 wds.) |
| 43% | THEBLACKPANTHER | 15 | Comic book character with the title role in a blockbuster 2018 film |
| 43% | RIGHTONR | 8 | Legal maneuver ... with a hint to answering seven clues in this puzzle |
| 43% | DISCO | 5 | With 8-Down, "The Simpsons" character in a rhinestone suit |
| 43% | STUDY | 5 | Room with a secret passage to the kitchen in the board game Clue |
| 43% | EDNORTON | 8 | Glass Onion actor who shares his name with a character in The Honeymooners |
| 42% | SUPERHERO | 9 | The character with special powers in a comic book |
| 42% | AQUATEEN | 8 | Any of three title characters in a long-running Cartoon Network series |
| 42% | GUMMIBEAR | 9 | Any of several colorful, anthropomorphic characters in a candy-inspired Disney series |
| 42% | DISCO | 5 | With 4-Down, "The Simpsons" character in a rhinestone-studded leisure suit |
| 42% | IRON | 4 | Monopoly token replaced with a cat in 2013 |
| 41% | Y=X | 3 | Basic linear expression with a hint to answering the five starred clues in this puzzle |
| 41% | ANNAKARENINA | 12 | Title character in a love triangle with two men named Alexei |