| 100% | YOST | 4 | Baseball's Eddie, 1952 All-Star for the Senators |
| 44% | MOBY | 4 | Electronic musician known for the song "We Are All Made of Stars" |
| 44% | CURT | 4 | With 15-Across, three-time MLB All-Star whose Supreme Court battle paved the way for baseball free agency |
| 43% | SYLVESTERSTALLONE | 17 | The bartender poured beers for all the action movie stars, including ___ |
| 42% | LOVE | 4 | "___ Story," 1970 film starring Ray Milland that's one of the highest-grossing films of all time adjusted for inflation |
| 41% | MAGENDAVID | 10 | Name for the star on Israel's flag |
| 41% | ICE | 3 | Surface for the Senators |
| 41% | POCKETS | 7 | Keeps for oneself ... or features of the answers to all the starred clues |
| 41% | TONYOLIVA | 9 | Eight-time All-Star for the Minnesota Twins who was inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame in 2022 (2 wds.) |
| 40% | MVP | 3 | Award for the Super Bowl's star athlete: Abbr. |
| 40% | ACES | 4 | Pitchers likely to be selected for the All-Star Game |
| 39% | OXTAILS | 7 | Animal parts used for stews, or what the answers to the starred clues all have |
| 39% | REACH | 5 | ___ for the stars |
| 39% | AIM | 3 | "___ for the stars..." |
| 39% | AIM | 3 | "___ for the stars ..." |
| 39% | REACH | 5 | "___ for the stars" |
| 39% | HANKAARON | 9 | Record holder for the most M.L.B. All-Star selections |
| 39% | YUDARVISH | 9 | Five-time All-Star who's the first Japanese pitcher with 2,000 strikeouts in Major League Baseball |
| 39% | EXPANSIONTEAM | 13 | The NHL's North Stars in 1967, for one? |
| 39% | FLATRATE | 8 | It's the same for all customers |
| 39% | TAFT | 4 | Eisenhower's rival for the 1952 nomination |
| 39% | KLAY | 4 | ___ Thompson, star for the Golden State Warriors |
| 39% | DRESSEDUP | 9 | All ready for the ball |
| 39% | AIM | 3 | "___ for the stars.." (shoot) |
| 39% | AIM | 3 | "___ for the stars..." (aspire) |
| 38% | FINAL | 5 | Tournament round that's for all the marbles |
| 38% | LEAD | 4 | Role for the star |
| 38% | SUPERBOWLMVP | 12 | Award for the star of the NFL's biggest game: 3 wds., abbr. |
| 38% | ASPIRE | 6 | Reach for the stars |
| 38% | LIMO | 4 | Stretch for the stars? |