| 100% | SCARECROW | 9 | Baum character who didn't have a brain |
| 47% | SCARECROW | 9 | Wizard of Oz character who wanted a brain |
| 45% | BART | 4 | TV character who says "Don't have a cow, man!" |
| 45% | TINA | 4 | "Glee" character who had a fake stutter |
| 45% | JOSEPH | 6 | Biblical character who had a colorful "dreamcoat" |
| 45% | OLAF | 4 | Disney character who has a carrot nose |
| 45% | LINUS | 5 | Cartoon character who has a security blanket |
| 44% | IGOR | 4 | "Young Frankenstein" character who has a notable hump |
| 44% | OLAF | 4 | "Frozen" character who says "I don't have a skull. Or bones." |
| 43% | LEO | 3 | Character who has his eyebrows singed off in a "Seinfeld" episode |
| 43% | APU | 3 | "The Simpsons" character who has a brother named Sanjay |
| 43% | DOUG | 4 | Cartoon character who had a crush on Patti Mayonnaise |
| 43% | ELMO | 4 | "Sesame Street" character who has a goldfish named Dorothy |
| 43% | PAM | 3 | "The Office" character who had a romance with Jim |
| 43% | NORM | 4 | "Cheers" character who had a never-seen wife named Vera |
| 43% | APU | 3 | "The Simpsons" character who has a PhD in computer science |
| 43% | MICKEYMOUSE | 11 | Cartoon character who once had a "Club" named after him |
| 43% | RED | 3 | ___ Riding Hood, fictional character who has a "danger-colored" name |
| 43% | BLACK | 5 | ___ Widow, fictional Marvel character who has a "charcoal-colored" name |
| 43% | HUMPTYDUMPTY | 12 | Nursery rhyme character who had a great fall (2 wds.) |
| 42% | MADEA | 5 | Tyler Perry character who had a "Homecoming" in a 2022 film |
| 42% | SILVER | 6 | The ___ Surfer, fictional Marvel character who has a "metallic-colored" name |
| 42% | GREEN | 5 | ___ Lantern, fictional DC Comics character who has a "nature-colored" name |
| 42% | PINK | 4 | The ___ Panther, fictional animated character who has a "flamingo-colored" name |
| 42% | PETERPAN | 8 | J. M. Barrie character who didn't grow up |
| 41% | DOROTHY | 7 | Character who sings with the Scarecrow in "If I Only Had a Brain" |
| 41% | CINDERELLA | 10 | Disney character who didn't want the other shoe to drop? |
| 40% | PLUTO | 5 | Disney character who may have been named in 1931 for a newly discovered planet |
| 40% | MURPHYBROWN | 11 | Candice Bergen's "colorful" TV character who had trouble keeping a secretary (2 wds.) |
| 40% | XXXXXX | 6 | Didn't have to retake, as a class |