| 100% | DEIST | 5 | Believer who doesn't believe in miracles |
| 63% | ATHEIST | 7 | Person who doesn't believe in god |
| 63% | ATHEIST | 7 | Someone who doesn't believe in God |
| 62% | ATHEIST | 7 | One who doesn't believe in a deity |
| 61% | ATHEIST | 7 | One who doesn't believe in God or gods |
| 58% | AGNOSTIC | 8 | Someone who doesn't believe or disbelieve in God |
| 54% | DEIST | 5 | One who does not believe in miracles |
| 53% | REBEL | 5 | "What do you call a kid who doesn't believe in Santa? A ___ without a Claus!" |
| 52% | DEIST | 5 | Believer in a creator who doesn't intervene |
| 49% | INFIDEL | 7 | One who doesn't believe |
| 47% | DENIER | 6 | One who doesn't believe the truth |
| 47% | FLATEARTHSOCIETY | 16 | Group that doesn't believe in revolution? |
| 46% | GOD | 3 | What an atheist doesn't believe in |
| 45% | ACE | 3 | Person who doesn't experience sexual attraction, in slang |
| 45% | AFISHOUTOFWATER | 15 | One who doesn't fit in |
| 45% | OUTSIDER | 8 | Person who doesn't fit in |
| 44% | ATHEISTS | 8 | People who don't believe in God |
| 44% | HEADS | 5 | Call from someone who doesn't believe "tails never fails" |
| 44% | TOYSRUSKID | 10 | One who doesn't want to grow up, in a jingle |
| 44% | UNITARIANS | 10 | Christians who don't believe in the Trinity |
| 44% | ODDMANOUT | 9 | One who doesn't click in a clique |
| 43% | MISFIT | 6 | Someone who doesn't belong in a social situation |
| 43% | ODDONEOUT | 9 | An individual who doesn't fit in |
| 42% | MIME | 4 | Artist who doesn't speak and who might be "trapped in a box" |
| 42% | ALMICHAELS | 10 | Sportscaster who memorably asked "Do you believe in miracles?" |
| 40% | IGOR | 4 | Lab assistant who doesn't appear in Mary Shelley's novel |
| 40% | MISFIT | 6 | An outsider; someone who doesn't blend in |
| 38% | DEISM | 5 | Belief in a creator who doesn't intervene |
| 37% | DUH | 3 | Who doesn't know that?! |
| 37% | IGOR | 4 | "Frankenstein" lab assistant who doesn't appear in Mary Shelley's novel |