| 100% | GRENDEL | 7 | Beowulf defeats this dark creature |
| 35% | WEREWOLF | 8 | Full moon transforms this creature |
| 34% | STOUTS | 6 | Roasted malts make these dark beers |
| 34% | CHOCOLATEMOOSE | 14 | Dark brown forest creature? |
| 33% | JELLYFISH | 9 | This gelatinous sea creature stings |
| 33% | TORTOISE | 8 | This creature beat the hare |
| 32% | GRENDEL | 7 | Monster defeated by Beowulf |
| 31% | CENTIPEDE | 9 | This creature can have hundreds of legs |
| 31% | THECAT | 6 | Curiosity killed this feline creature |
| 30% | MILLS | 5 | "And was Jerusalem builded here / Among these dark Satanic __?": Blake |
| 30% | OCTOPUS | 7 | Creature suggested by this puzzle's circled letters |
| 30% | SPIDERS | 7 | These itsy-bitsy creatures climb up the waterspout |
| 30% | WEREWOLF | 8 | Remus Lupin was secretly this creature |
| 29% | CLOWNFISH | 9 | Nemo is this type of sea creature |
| 29% | SNOWMAN | 7 | Frosty was this kind of cold creature |
| 29% | HOBBIT | 6 | Frodo Baggins is this kind of creature |
| 29% | HOBBIT | 6 | Frodo Baggins is this type of creature |
| 29% | WATERLOO | 8 | Napoleon was defeated in this 1815 battle |
| 29% | SNAILS | 6 | Escargot is a dish of these creatures |
| 28% | POLARBEAR | 9 | Lorek is this animal in His Dark Materials |
| 28% | MERMAID | 7 | Ariel is this kind of mythical sea creature |
| 28% | TROLL | 5 | The Three Billy Goats Gruff tricked this creature |
| 28% | {LOVE}BUG | 9 | "Darling" creature found five times in this puzzle |
| 28% | SKEKSIS | 7 | Evil reptile/bird creatures in The Dark Crystal |
| 28% | TWOSUNS | 7 | Luke stares at these on Tatooine before dark |
| 28% | SALAMIS | 7 | Greeks defeated the Persians at this sea battle |
| 28% | LAGOON | 6 | Reptilian creatures live in this body of water |
| 28% | WHALESONG | 9 | Spas use this soothing sound from ocean creatures |
| 28% | DINOSAURS | 9 | The Chicxulub Crater is related to these creatures |
| 28% | ZOMBIES | 7 | The Walking Dead is overrun with these creatures |